thanks! I used the DH Devils food for a milder chocolate taste and it was wonderful!
Fantastic cake. Only problem I had is I didn't leave the cream cheese out long enough. It sat out for quite a while but didn't break down enough so I had little white chunks in my batter. Tip - Let the cream cheese super soften!!!!
Made the cake again - FANTASTIC!!! No problems
DC0630--you used cream cheese instead of sour cream? What made you change it? I bet it is great with cream cheese as well!
Cupcakes made with this recipe turned out nicely domed (Rises EASILY). Baked at 350. No 400 degree prebake needed it rises nicely. Nice dark chocolately. Makes 36 to 48 CC for HALF the recipe depending on your CC pan size.
AWESOME! Very moist and great chocolate flavor.
Hey, I made this recipe Friday and it would not come out of the pan and when I tried to pick it up to torte & layer it fell all to pieces....I used the DH Fudge Butter Recipe (without using butter)..... Do you think that could of made it stick and fall apart... Loved the taste of the cake... Any help you can give me I would greatly appreciate... Thank you
This is def one of my favorite chocolate cake recipes but it is very very moist so I freeze before trying to work with it,
Its MUCH too moist to cut or torte right out of the pan. I take it out of the oven, let it sit 10 min, then flip it on a cooling rack and immediately on a board with saran wrap on it. I then wrap it completely in saran and pop it in the freezer for about 2 hours at least. Then its cool and sometimes partially frozen so its much easier to handle.
Does this recipe work well for tiered cakes? I need a chocolate cake for a wedding-- 12", 8" and 4" 2-layer tiers so I want something that holds up well (firm, easy to stack). I just have 2" pans so do I need to make this twice to fill these pans ?
Does this work well for rectangular cakes? What size with this recipe make? Sounds yummy!
Yummy! This was a very rich chocolate recipe! The batter filled my poor little KitchenAid to the top. I was able to get 2 ea. 8inch/6inch rounds (2inches high), plus some extra cupcakes for sampling. I froze them for about a week before removing from the freezer to stack. They were a little 'soft' after thawing, but they iced with BC well. The cake sat overnight at RT, and was served the next day around 6pm. The cake was still moist and delicious!
I've made this recipe SEVERAL times and never have I been disappointed. So I figured, if I can use it with a chocolate cake mix, why not with other flavors. So far I've made spice, yellow, lemon, and chocolate, and ALL of them come out FANTASTIC!! Of course with other mixes than chocolate, I do not add the coffee. :o) I've also received several request for making cakes just because of this recipe.
I made this tonight it is simply AMAZING!!! Very Moist and just perfect! i was worried about the sour cream how it would taste in the cake you can not tell there's any sour cream. I did leave out the coffee but overall I love this recipe and will be using it from now on!!!
If the coffee is left out of this recipe, should something be added in its place? I am desperate to find a moist chocolate cake recipe - I am making a pirate ship cake and need something that will carve and hold up to stacking and fondant. Help!!! Anyone??? :-)
I've thrown out all my other chocolate cake recipes. This IS the perfect chocolate cake I've been searching for. Thanks so much for the recipe, Cakepro!
I am making this one right now and from what I tasted YUMMY!. I was able to make a 10x3 & a 8x3. I also used Devils Food Cake Mix and no coffee. I can't wait to try this!
Has anyone used this recipe for a shaped cake? Making my son an elmo cake for his birthday and want to know if it is too moist of a cake for that.
I turned these into 3 dozen cupcakes, and because there was so much batter, I also made a few 6x3 cakes (4 to be exact).
This cake is delicious...very moist. I didn't have a good experience carving or stacking though. It was much to light and moist to stack well. However, for a single tier cake, it's perfect!
Will this cake work for a two tier cake? I need a good choc recipe for a groom's cake.... I plan on using buttercream and fondant. Any help would be greatly appreciated.
Just got another request for this cake. It really does taste perfect. Not too sweet/cloying.
What's the flower nail for? Just curious. ;)
My most favorite and customers most favorite chocolate cake, self frosting, moist, just plain delish. Easy recipe to alter with other flavors as well.
I have made this 4 times now with BC Triple Choc Fudge cake mix and it is just wonderful! Also, I use 3/4 T instant espresso powder.
This cake is great to work with, easy to stack and stays very moist.
Schmoozy-- the nail flower is to help the cake turn out more level, so you don't have to cut as much off the top to make it flat.
Could someone please tell me how full I should fill the pans with this batter (1/2 full? 2/3 full?)? I tend to overfill...
I don't even like chocolate cake but this was great!
Someone tell me if this cake will fill an 11 x 15 x 2" cake pan....I've made it twice and both times it overflowed my pan and sunk in some, even with the flower nail..... :( Love the taste but can't quite get it to come out the same each time...don't know what I'm doing wrong...:(
this is my "go to" chocolate cake. I personally like to fill it with a kaluha bavarian cream. Tastes fantastic! GREAT RECIPE!!!
can i use this recipe for cupcakes?
For those that have a question about how much batter this makes here is what I get. I fill my 11x15x2 sheet cake pan about 2/3 full and put in 4 flower nails. I then have enough batter left for 12 reg size cupcakes. This rises quite a bit so don't get too crazy filling the pan.
Thought I'd add, this batter makes enough for one 11x15x3 :)
I'm not 100% as I've yet to make this recipe, but most of the WASC recipes make about 15-17 cups, depending on your cake mix brand and everything. I use DH and almost always get 17 cups. Hope that helps
Very excited to try this recipe.. I have been testing several chocolate cakes, and I always have to triple or quad a regular recipe to fill a 10inch. Looking foward to this one. Just a quick question, I know some of you have posted that this rises easily, anyone have the exact cup measure they use for a 10 x 3? Thanks!
I am going to try to amp up the coffee flavor with starbucks new instant coffee. I know I have said this before but I LOVE LOVE this cake. I am on my 8th request.
I'm going to make a 3 tier topsy turvy cake for Saturday, 3 layers for each tier. Has anyone stacked multiple layers with the recipe? They want chocolate with chocolate mouse filling. I'm a little worried about the mouse making the cake unstable between layers and then driven an hour.
Just made half the recipe for my mickey mouse cake order and it came out FANTASTIC! I did replace half the vanilla for Nielsen's chocolate pure chocolate extract...got that idea from Macsmom's chocolate WASC recipe.
I just tried this recipe and it was great! And I'm not even a chocolate lover! With the recipe as is I got two 2"x10" round cakes and two 2x6" round cakes. Which is certainly convenient if you're making a huge stacked cake!
I need enough batter for a single layer 10' (bottom is chocolate and top is white cake) and 12 cupcakes. How would I split up the recipe? It sounds like it makes alot! Would I split it in half? Help! Thanks! :)
Thank you for this recipe! I made it this weekend and everyone loved it! :)
i'm going to make this for the groom's cake for my daughter's wedding. However, when there was a sale on cake mixes, 10 for $10 i bought all white ones. Does anyone have a suggestion on how much cocoa powder to add to the above recipe to make it a deep dark chocolate cake? I hate to mess with perfection, but its the wedding and i'm 'spent out' if you know what i mean. thanks!
So, a few people have said that this doesn't carve well. What if you freeze it first? I'm looking for a new recipes to try my hand at a topsy turvy cake. Would this work, or is it still too soft, even if it's frozen?
Made and did not like.... to crumbly, flavor wasn't there (super sweet) ... overall not happy. Thank you for posting it, I appreciate it. I reverted to the Cake Mix Dr's version of pound cake. :D <3
The tester cake for my daughter's wedding is in the oven. What would be the perfect filling for this cake?
This recipe sounds yummy..! I'm going to make a tester cake today with oreo filling. Let's see how it goes. I will post my review later today :)
Does anyone know how this would turn out if we divided the recipe in half and used just two eggs? Making a last-minute cake for a family thing tonight, and we are short on eggs! Thanks
for the water is 2 cups plus 2/3 cup ????
upssss yes!! :)
can you use this recipe for a stacked cake or is it too soft and crumbly?
Made this cake this morning. DELICIOUS! Go 2- 10ich X 2inch cakes and 1 8 inch X 2 inch.
Ok stupid question but the coffee are we talking brewed coffee? right not just a scoop of instant coffee?
bbblues2see, yes the coffee is brewed ...not the granules.
After reading my reply I think I still left room for confusion about the coffee. You can use granules if you dissolve them in liquid first. The whole point is that the coffee be in liquid form and you aren't dumping coffee grounds/granules in the batter.
Hi, If I do nto want to use sour cream (sensitive tummy ) what can I use in its place?
Princess you could probably use Greek yogurt. It is very similar to sour cream.
Try this recipe today and fell in love with it i'm not a baker so for me to get this right shows how easy it is. This is my go to recipe for chocolate cake now thank you so much
This is my favorite chocolate cake recipe. I have made it many times and get requests for it all the time. I do not have any problems stacking this cake.
Making this cake tonight for a customer and I put a 6" in the oven for a tester. I sure hope this comes out great. I need a good chocolate cake recipe. :)
This is the ONLY recipe I use for chocolate cake! I've made this recipe so many times with the Very Special Buttercream recipe that I got from this site! People love it! Also, wanted to throw out there that I have used this recipe with Dunkin Hines French Vanilla Cake, Red Velvet and Spice Cake instead of Dark Chocolate Cake Mix and omitted the coffee (just used plain water) and it is fantastic!!!! Especially the French Vanilla Cake :) Thanks for sharing :)
Was MOST DISAPPOINTED with this recipe! UGH! All the rave reviews. The cake baked perfectly on the outside and sank in the middle and crinkled up on the middle top. Worse...when I let the cake cool in the freezer and out on the counter, I torted the cake only to see that that middle WAS NOT BAKED FULLY! I was so pissed off that I ended up cutting out a huge inner circle chunk of the half baked cake and dumped it. BTW The cake tester came out clean all over the cake including the middle! I ended up filling the big whole of the two layer cake with BC chocolate fudge icing.
The jokey part about all of this is that the customer wrote back 2 days later to say that the cakes were great. I was like..good lord good thing I cut out the uncooked middle!
I think I'm gonna stick to my scratch chocolate cake recipe. This one tastes too artificial for me and bcuz I sell cakes to the public I cannot afford any loss of customers from an uncooked cake.
Has anyone had this same problem of the sinking in the middle and the uncooked part?!?!
Pearl645, I've made this a couple times and it's been fantastic but when I made it today I had the exact same experience you described. So I re-baked. Same thing happened. Now it's 10:30 and I have to re-bake again. Wish I knew what was going on! Anyone have any answers?
This is the ONLY Chocolate cake recipe I use!!! Baked one yesterday and it turned out fantastic again!! Mine only sank once and seemed uncooked, I changed my oven temp to 325 bake them a little longer now and never open the oven to check until they are almost done! Excellent cake to ice and fill with cream cheese frosting!!! Love it!
WOW this was YUMMY! I only got to sample the parts I trimmed off but it was very moist and very tasty! Thank you for this recipe!
This is by far the best chocolate cake I have EVER tasted! It is now my only chocolate cake recipe. The only negative thing I can say is it is a softer cake, so carving/sculpting would probably be difficult. But if you are not carving it, this cake is absolutely the best! Other than that it is perfect!
I use 1 tbl instant coffee granules mixed into the water. I've stacked and carved this cake with no problems....baked, cooled and frozen ahead of time. A flower nail or core is essential for larger pans to get this cake baked through to the middle. It does stay a little tacky on the top when you trim to level. It's my go to cake for chocolate. I fill with either chocolate buttercream, oreo buttercream, or peanut butter chocolate buttercream. A tweenkie filling would be good too.
You might be experiencing the underbaked problem with the DH cake mix because (in case you haven't noticed) they are 16.5oz now and not 18.25. More liquid and less solid is probably the culprit in a wetter result!
I've made this cake three or four times now and absolutely love it!!! It's perfect....rises beautifullly....made it as rounds (both 2 and 3" deep), cupcakes and sheets. Just watch the baking time...don't open the door until you're pretty sure it is almost done...this is definitely my go to Chocolate Cake!!!!! Just wish it would stack but definitely see where it would collapse under the weight. Overall though, this is a perfect 10 for me for anything other than tiers.
Okay this is my favorite tasting cake and every time I make it everyone tells me it is the best tasting cake they have ever had. That said I made this cake for my cousins wedding and the bottom layer of each tier started collapsing and the butter cream was budging out from between the layers. Not sure what went wrong. The cakes were 14"x3, 10'x3 and 6"x3. I doweled each tier. This has happened before with other cakes. Please help if you can I will take any advise.
This is my go to chocolate cake. My husband doesn't usually like chocolate cake but will eat this every time! Just put a 12X18 in the oven and this recipe made just the right amount although I expect it to be close to bubbling over. We'll see!
I have baked this recipe 100x now. I am not joking. Everyone who tastes it loves it. This has been my go to chocolate cake recipe for almost one year. LOVE IT!!! Yes, the amounts are smaller now in the duncan hines, but I don't use any other brand. I have tried them and they just don't work. The only problem I have had with the less amount in the box is that it doesn't make up the same amount of batter as before. About 1 whole cup less. Stinks but I won't change a thing.
I just baked a 12x18"sheet cake and had FABULOUS RESULTS! I will tell you that i did just as the directions said... This entire batter fills a 12x18" pan perfectly to 2/3-3/4 full. In addition, instead of the flower nail method (Ihavent had great luck with it when the nail falls in the batter!!!) i used an old towel cut to the size of the pan, and drenched it in water, wrang out slightly so it wouldnt drip than used that as a bake even strip. My cake is completely LEVEL! Im thinking Im not gonna level it bc its perfect. The cake rose to the edge of the 2" pan with NO SPILLAGE. I baked the cake for 1HOUR 10 MINUTES. Checked it with a tooth pick and its completely done in the middle!!! No JIGGLE! Im gonna used this cake with an oreo filling and vanilla buttercream icing.
I can't wait to try this recipe out. Thank you.
Hello! Has anyone tried this same recipe using other flavor cake mixes? I just made cupcakes using this exact recipe only differencewas iI'm the oil. I used 2tblsp of oil instead of 1/4 and it was just too dense and moist. I will bake another batch tomorrow but will use 1/4 c oil as it says on cakepros recipe. Thanks ahead of time
Please note that this recipe was written when the Duncan Hines cake mixes were all 18.25 ounces. If you are using a boxed mix that is 16.5 ounces, you will need to add an additional 1/3 cup of mix PER BOX. If you are using the ever-shrinking 15.25 ounce box of cake mix, I recommend you use a kitchen scale and add 3 ounces of mix (by weight, of course) to each box of cake mix. It's much easier to add additional cake mix to the original recipe than scale all of the other ingredients downward to accommodate the smaller and smaller sizes of cake mixes.
What size box DH? Should I add to the smaller box size using a second boxed mix? Thanks!
I have played with this recipe and no longer use oil or water. Instead unsalted butter and whole milk. Actually, the last one I made was with buttermilk and that is my favorite so far. I make one box at a time but I have always kept the vanilla and coffee granuals, at 1Tbls. Okay, I'll admit...it was by accident the first couple times...but when I reduced both...the "box" flavor still came through.
There have been several questions about the use of the flower nail. They are used to distribute heat to the center of a deep cake that wouldn't get done before the outside is done. Also, when you have a deep cake or any cake for that matter, use wet towel strip wrapped around the cake pan. This will help keep the outside edge from getting overdone and dry before the center is done. These strips are also sold commercially, but they are expensive. I would find someone with a surger or zig-zag sewing machine and use your old, worn out bath towels cut in strips. I would make two layers, but some have success with one. The stitching is used to keep the toweling from raveling and leaving bits of toweling all over. The advantage of making your own is that you can make it as wide as you want. The formula for determining length is 2Pi R. That is 2X3.1416X the radius (1/2 the diameter of your pan). Add enough so that you can tuck the end without using pins. Then you can adjust your baking time for the center of the pan. If you have a convection oven, lower the temperature 20 to 25 degrees.