Need Good Buttercream To Stand Up Against Heat And Humidity?
Decorating By 29apr00 Updated 8 Jun 2018 , 9:35pm by Vergaline
My sister is getting married the end of July She wants me to make her wedding cake. 4 tiers OUTSIDE at the lake All in buttercream with fresh gerber daisy's.
I believe she is insane, but she wants it. So now i'm determined to give it to her. Now i use Buttercream Dream from here, and add a few tablespoons Merigune powder to it. But it still seems just so soft and I'm sure 90degree heat and about 99% humidity, i'm sure this cake is bound to melt.
So is there another icing that will stand up better?? She and her fiance don't like the taste and texture of fondant (it's not very popular around here) so that's out.
Jennifer
Use all crisco, no butter, add some butter flavoring if you want. Make it a little stiffer than you are used to. I can't promise it will stand up for more than a couple hours in that heat, but it will definately be better than regular BC.
The all Crisco is probably your safest bet, but I've never had an ounce of trouble with the Wilton 1/2 and 1/2 (1/2 butter, 1/2 crisco) recipe. I find that the taste of this is much better. Personally, I can't stand the all crisco taste, even with the butter flavoring.
HTH --- S.
I use High Humidity Buttercream and have never had a problem even in August when is 100 degrees.
1/2 tsp salt
1 1/2c crisco
3 Tbls. Dream Whip
3 drops butter flavoring
1/2 tsp. Clear Vanilla
3 drops lemon or orange flavoring, optional
1/4 c. flour
1/2 c. milk
2lb 10x sugar
Mix salt, crisco, dream whip and flavorings together on high speed 4-7 min. until mix. resembles whipped cream. Add flour, 1/2 of the milk and 1/2 of the sugar, Mix until blended. Add remaining milk and sugar and mix until blended.
This is a crusting buttercream so I keep bowl covered with a damp towel to keep it from crusting while I decorating with it. make enough to ice and decorate a 1/4 sheet cake. I will post this in the recipe section also. Hope this helps.
Val
Hi-ratio shortening has the highest melting point; Alpine brand is the best, then Sweetex. Do not use any butter, but use one teaspoon butter extract flavoring for every pound of powdered sugar/every cup of Alpine/Sweetex. Make sure the cake is in the shade--no cake can handle direct sunlight.
All crisco reminds me of the Wilton Class Buttercream.
Val - that is WONDERFUL!! 1 question? What is Dream whip??
Dream whip is a powdered whip topping mix. Just bought some more today at Walmart it is in the baking isle above the pudding mixes (at least in my store) The boxes have 2 or 4 pkts of powder in them, each batch of icing uses almost 1 pkt. I think it was like $2 for the sm 2 pkt box. I have use the store brands of whipped topping mix too without it changing the icing taste or texture.
Val
I live in Mississippi, the capital of heat and humidity! I use the all crisco recipe. I cup of crisco, 1/2 cup ( + or -) of water, 2 lbs. powered sugar, 1 tsp vanilla extract, 1 tsp of almond extract. I have recently found out that crisco has changed their recipe and now uses no trans fats so what this means is that it doesn't whip up quite as fluffy and the colors don't blend as good. So I now use shortening that has the trans fats in it. That is a personal choice, the taste is the same,however. This recipe does great in any weather. Good luck
I live in Mississippi, the capital of heat and humidity! I use the all crisco recipe. I cup of crisco, 1/2 cup ( + or -) of water, 2 lbs. powered sugar, 1 tsp vanilla extract, 1 tsp of almond extract. I have recently found out that crisco has changed their recipe and now uses no trans fats so what this means is that it doesn't whip up quite as fluffy and the colors don't blend as good. So I now use shortening that has the trans fats in it. That is a personal choice, the taste is the same,however. This recipe does great in any weather. Good luck
I use the all shortening method also, here in HOT sunny Florida. I've known people that said my cakes have survived all-day swim parties, as long as the cake was in a shaded area and the Mom's weren't sitting too close to eat it all.
Beware the "no trans fats" shortenings though.
Thanks for this recipe Val...I'll be tring this...Pennsylvania can get pretty humid YUCK!
Thanks for this recipe, I will try it now that summer is here & Hawaii gets pretty humid too.
Here are some hi-ratio frosting recipes for hot weather:
(Delicious even when weather isn't a consideration.)
http://www.cakecentral.com/cake_recipe-2375-Brite-White-Buttercream-Icing.html
CAROLYNS (MO) BUTTERCREAM ICING
(Also from cakesbygeorge.)
http://www.cakesbygeorge.com/recipes/Recipes/carolyn_lawrence.htm
Multi-linked super thread on hi-ratio shortening; (What it is, where to get it, how to use it and more recipes. )
http://www.cakecentral.com/cake-decorating-ftopict-264563-.html
Also includes info on Brite White or Angel White icing base and Creme Bouquet.
6x vs. 10x Powdered Sugar:
http://www.cakecentral.com/cake-decorating-ftopicp-643383-.html
HTH
Edited to fix broken links.
Just wanted to give feedback on Val's recipe because I made a batch this weekend and it is sooooooooooo good!!!! Other than that, it crusts beautifully. Viva and Melvira method works well with this BC. I substituted the milk with coffee creamer (caramel hazelnut) and it was superb!!!
Val- You just saved me!!! My nieces graduation party is June 23rd outside at a park. Im making her cake. It's already been hitting 80-90 degree weather here and its only May. I will definitely be trying this recipe! Any suggestions on the best way to make it chocolate??? And how well does it take color?? Of course I have red and black layers! Im planning on doing the black color in chocolate frosting so I don't have to use a ton.
I have only flavored it once (this week) using white choc. rasp. coffee creamer. That was yummy!! I haven't had a problem with coloring it yet. I haven't posted any pics except these of my daughter. She is "decorating" with this icing. Not sure how to post link. Topic is first time "decorator" it is in the general forum. Should give you an idea on how well it takes color. I only used a little of wilton color in it.
Val
Fooby - thanks for being the test subject! I can't wait to try this recipe!
You're welcome. I guess being a hobbyist gives me the time to test recipes and test it on my guinea pigs at home One thing's for sure, I am not going back to buttercream dream
Ohhhhh, wish I had seen this recipe 2 hours ago, before I made a batch of CC crusting buttercream (1/2 butter, 1/2 crisco)!!!! So, this is my next recipe to try....because it is hot and humid here today!!!
Along these lines, quick question.....have just finished icing a cake with my 1/2 and 1/2 recipe and will be putting a chocolate ganache over it as well for a bridal shower tomorrow....here's the question (couldn't find in a search) - does this have to be refrigerated?????? I'm trying to figure out how in the world I will get it in my fridge stacked...cuz I didn't think of that in the first place Not that it is a huge cake, it isn't, but there is a major lack of space right now!!!! If I'm safe keeping it boxed on the counter until I deliver tomorrow then I will! Otherwise, something has to go....maybe DH's diet Mt Dew
Thanks for any input!!! I am hoping this cake leads to some orders (fingers crossed).
It isn't necessary to refrigerate this b/c and ganache to prevent spoilage.
However, it will firm up the frosting a bit - so don't know if this might be something you'd want to do because of the weather.
HTH
JanH you are the BEST!!!!! Thank you so much!!!! I will try and make room and plan better next time....I think I just got too excited!
Love the chart!
ohhh nooooo! Crisco is bad!!! you should use hi-ratio shortening!! (you use it in the same way that you use crisco)
Quote by @%username% on %date%
%body%