Fluffy White Filling Be The First To Review By Anonymous recipe This fluffy white filling is made with butter, shortening and evaporated milk. Fluffy White Filling Ingredients 1/2 cup butter1/2 cup shortening1 cup white sugar3/4 cup evaporated milk1 tablespoon vanilla extract Instructions 1 In a large bowl, cream butter for 5 minutes. Add shortening and cream for another 5 minutes. Beat in sugar. Add evaporated milk and vanilla. Beat until very light and fluffy.