This was another free one for an annual party we go to, I had so many orders that week that I felt this one got snubbed. I loved the pumpkin when it was just a pumpkin, I should have left it that way. I don't like the jackolantern part or the cat, which kinda looks like a bunny according to my hubby. Oh well, it tasted good, I tried the cookie layer thing. Chocolate cake with PB cookie and vanilla buttercream.