Several of them have already been signed and made records, actually. Yesterday I was reading an article (on Yahoo or something) about how many of them have already had their chance. One of them had like 5 songs on a movie soundtrack. Probably the girl with black hair that was so good. I'll try to find it and post the link.
So what's everyone's take on all that? Do you think they should get a chance to compete on AI if they've already been signed? I'm on the fence, but my gut tells me that maybe that should disqualify them...don't really know why I think that....just thinking out loud.
I'm not sure how I feel about that. My gut says that they had their chance, but I could probably be convinced otherwise.
For them to find the best singers year after year, who are complete amateurs, with no experience at all, might be difficult...so I'm ok with contestants who have been signed before or who have had other professional type gigs, as long as they haven't become well known in the process.
It's true they've had their chance, but I think the business is so brutal and unfair, alot of talented people don't get heard, and alot of manufactured singers become household names.
I think they deserve a second chance if they can actually sing.
What the h*ll happend with that girl Anne Marie? I watched it twice and still can't figure out why they wanted her to leave and come back as a "star"??
It made no sense...she WAS dressed down, but alot of people go in there looking much worse...she reminded me of Katherine McPhee actually, and her voice was the best of anyone shown.
I felt bad for the guy with the guitar...he was really hurt.
I wondered who else watched it last night. I missed the first 20 minutes because of a tasting appointment. I thought Anne Marie was awesome! I loved her before they made her change her image, although I couldn't tell much was changed. I felt sorry for guitar guy too. He was pretty good in alternative music, but I don't think he would've gone far in the competition. I liked the 16 year old with all the older siblings too. She was really good and I loved how her sisters loved her so much.
You can't forget to mention the bearded guy. OMGosh...I almost got a hernia trying not to laugh at him. Dear sweet Lord, that guy was awful. You need a great voice and a good personality to make it on AI and he had neither.
The girl they made go change her makeup, etc. could have been Kara's little sister. They looked so much alike to me.
How about the girl who brought her friend in to sit on Randy's lap.
Can't wait to see what happens in Hollywood.
I thought the girl who brought her friend in was going to knock it out of the park, choosing a song like "Lovin'You". She was awful!
As for last night...I liked the Osmond guy, his dad made me cry, didn't like his song choice though.
LOVED Rose (who lost both her parents), but wasn't blown away by her voice...I wanted her to be great after hearing what she's been through.
Simon was in a good mood, wasn't he?
Rose was the hippie girl at the end? Her face was beautiful, but her hair made it very hard to see her face. Definitely a different kind of voice.
The Osmond kid was good. Doesn't it seem like people would know by now not to use songs that are originally sung by bands.
I thought the girl with the baby firl and the tattooed arm was good, too.
I agree, the tat mom was great...really pretty too.
Rose should've worn shoes...her feet looked filthy. Simple flip-flops would have gone with her whole look.
Speaking of looks! How about the chubette in the garter and stockings...she looked really inappropriate.
Did I say chubette in garter & stockings? I meant the hottie!! The people in PR are off to a good start tonight. Had to switch to Spongebob for a few minutes, be back soon.
The guy with the giant ipod prop was so unfunny, and surely must be very annoying to those around him on a daily basis.
I can't believe they had reservations about the last girl, she was sooo good, to me. She got the ticket, but they weren't convinced at all.
So glad the auditions are over!
Oh, how about Glitter Girl...she returned with a new look and supposed new attitude, and ended up flipping Simon off again, LOL.
I felt the say way about the last girl too! They let some real goofballs in there yet they could not hear how good she sounded. AND THERE'S 4 JUDGES NOW......maybe they need more???? lol
Yea glitter girl still remains weird and RUDE as usual. She's just using her rudeness to get back on the show. Geeez come on AI!
Cannot wait til they weed out again!
UGH, glitter girl. Why waste any time on her at all?
I know! I would've preferred to see someone who made it through.
I hate when they show a collection of ticket holders running out, but they haven't showed their audition, so you get to see them (& their families) celebrating, but you have no clue what went on in the judging room. Were they good, great, did they beg??
OK - so who watched it last night? I am SOOOOO ready for bikini girl to get her one-way ticket back home. There are others on there that are WAY prettier than her, but it has become such a stupid bit with Randy and Simon that I could gag.
There were a few others that should go too. The guy that dresses up nerdy should be a comedian on America's Got Talent or something. He should've gotten the boot last night.
I agree with both your comments...bikini girl thinks too highly of herself...she needs to go away already! The doofus in the headband should follow!
I'm glad Rose (the no shoe wearin' hippy) did well. She looked knocked up to me, I wonder if she is?
The guy who begged his way through at the auditions, then dissed Simon's clothes when he got cut, needs to take lessons on a classy exit from the girl who asked for a second chance and was denied.
I love the guy from P.R. with the curly black hair, his voice was great.
The guy who begged his way through at the auditions, then dissed Simon's clothes when he got cut, needs to take lessons on a classy exit from the girl who asked for a second chance and was denied.
Excellent point. I couldn't agree more.
The guy who begged his way through at the auditions, then dissed Simon's clothes when he got cut, needs to take lessons on a classy exit from the girl who asked for a second chance and was denied.
Excellent point. I couldn't agree more.
My dh said that he's really showing potential future employers how he'll deal with rejection and stress.
I think they should've given "Norman Gentle" the headband freak the boot and kept the FBI girl instead. Her voice was better, IMO.
The guy from Puerto Rico is excellent. I'll be shocked if he doesn't make it pretty far.
Bikini girl is getting old. She needs to give up the sexy thing and just be a singer.
many of the guys sounded fabulous. I liked the black guy with the short fro, the guy whose wife died and his friend. I love that Seal song.
Weird headband man needs to go. Second chance girl deserved it more than him. Although, she left gracefully, I'm not a fan of the begging. The "it's my cousin's birthday" was too much.
Quote by @%username% on %date%
%body%