I have been using Wilton round and square pans for about a year now. I have never really felt like they give me a great product to work with (not awful, just not amazing). So while I was shopping around on Global Art, I ran across Magic Line and Fat Daddios pans. I have read about them in the forums before, but I want to know which one is better. Has anyone used both? Are there better pans out there? I just want (square) pans that have sharper corners, less rounded, something durable, quality, etc. Advice?
I just bought magic line square pans on the good advice of everyone here. I have to say I think I'm in love!! ![]()
The corners are so sharp and the cakes turned out of the pan so beautifully! I didn't even have to use any parchment paper. I got them on sale on Amazon for a really great price.
I have been using wiltons too for about a year & like you find them ok as a product, I've also heard so much about magic line but have been unable to buy them bc they are so expensive to ship to Europe and I can't find them here so I'll have to wait........!
I have tested both and really dont find a difference in the finished product-they are both great! However; I do find that I have to bake a lot longer in the magic line pans. Magic line seem heavier and more durable but as far as the final product I would say, for me, they have been equally fine.
Someone on CC did a side by side test over a year ago and posted pics. The discussion turned, mmm . . . contentious and the post was deleted. Go figure. Anyway, there was a marked difference in the browning and height of the cakes when compared side by side. There was a consensus that the ML pans produced better results. I don't want to dredge up all the findings in that old thread, because it would likely get me banned, but ML was the clear winner.
Magic Line. No question.
Ditto! ![]()
Quote by @%username% on %date%
%body%