Soy Allergy - Cake And Icing Recipe Needed Quick! Help!!!!

Baking By LaylasMommy Updated 3 Sep 2008 , 11:11pm by ceshell

LaylasMommy Cake Central Cake Decorator Profile
LaylasMommy Posted 1 Sep 2008 , 5:19am
post #1 of 4

I need a cake that is soy free. I would like a vanilla cake, but want to make sure it is safe for child.

I also need an icing recipe that is soy free. This is more concerning than the cake. I want something that holds up and decorates great... without being too sweet.

Please help!!! I have one week!


3 replies
ceshell Cake Central Cake Decorator Profile
ceshell Posted 1 Sep 2008 , 5:40am
post #2 of 4

Not to be dumb, but aren't most cakes and icings soy-free? At least scratch cakes; if you want to use a mix it could be as simple as reading the box carefully. The WASC is so popular here but I don't know if vanilla cake mix contains soy. Obviously you'd want to stay away from any recipe containing mayonnaise. Is soy hidden anywhere else?

Here's a thread with some great scratch recipes (also many posted on the original thread which it links to). For a sturdy, scratch cake I'd recommend the Sylvia Weinstock cake Icing, well, just depends on what you want. Butter/shortening/powdered sugar? Meringue buttercream? Chocolate? None contain soy that I know of... Sugarshack's icing gets rave reviews (and can be made w/Crisco if you can't get Sweetex), and indydebi's icing is popular (but I do not know if Dream Whip contains soy). Meringue buttercreams are delicious and less sweet, and they only contain butter, sugar and egg (plus vanilla or other desired flavoring). A great thread about SMBC or IMBC

Hope this helps!!

LaylasMommy Cake Central Cake Decorator Profile
LaylasMommy Posted 3 Sep 2008 , 7:47pm
post #3 of 4

Crisco contains soy, as well as margarine and vegetable oil... it seems to be hidden everywhere. I should have said that I have a cake recipe that is soy-free however icing is my dilemna. I want something to decorate with, fluffy, not too sweet, holds up in warm weather.... but cannot contain crisco.

Thanks for your help though!

ceshell Cake Central Cake Decorator Profile
ceshell Posted 3 Sep 2008 , 11:11pm
post #4 of 4

No problem! See, there you go w/the hidden ingredients, I did not know crisco contains soy but it seems so obvious now that you mention it. (As for cakes even though you said you now have a recipe, you could stick with any butter cake or also what about pure corn oil (rather than "vegetable oil" )?

I understand your icing dilemma now, if you need fluffy AND holds up in the heat. IMBC/SMBC are silky (perhaps not fluffy) but definitely not too sweet, and IMBC holds up well in warm weather as long as you are not talking about HOT weather. I think the figure I'm used to seeing thrown around is about 80 degrees or so. It might be worth a shot.

You might try to find out the ingredients in Pastry Pride (if available in your area) or Rich's Bettercream or Frostin' Pride. I couldn't figure it out and I don't have a carton on hand, but I noticed Cool Whip does not appear to contain soy (I'm only using it as a comparison since it's a nondairy topping even tho it's not suitable as icing). Who knows though, for stability they may include the soybean oil icon_sad.gif.

Quote by @%username% on %date%