I am looking to make a cake for the employees at work tomorrow morning . We always have a tuesday morning meeting and coffee. I was going through recipes to see if a new recipe hits me when I noticed that the recipes for Gooey Butter Cake and the Neiman Marcus Cake 2 were very similiar...has anyone tried both of these cakes for comparison? They both have a 5 star recipe so I probably won't go wrong with either one of them.

Has anyone tried just one of these recipes? I wish the 'rating' system had a 'comment' section...

i know this is an very old thread, but i just came across these recipes today and had the same question. any info would be greatly appreciated!

The gooey butter cake I has 11 votes, 4.72 rating.

The Neiman Marcus II has 3 votes, 3.33 rating.

Which ever you make, be sure to vote