Cake Central › Cake Forums › Cake Talk › Cake Decorating › Small scale RBC vs. MMF
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Small scale RBC vs. MMF

post #1 of 4
Thread Starter 
So, I've been lurking around trying to figure out what to use to make these small (1/2" x 1" at the biggest) squares around the bottom of each tier of a five tier wedding cake. The tiers are to be covered in white-as-I-can-get smoothed buttercream (Viva method) and the squares are in jewel-tones. No other decorations on the cake. I have read that RBC is terrible for covering a cake but works well for small things. I have only worked with store-bought fondant and want something tastier.

RBC - I have read it is greasy and will probably be shiny. Also that it will not harden - which is no big deal. The squares will be put on the morning of delivery. I have read that some people have successfully replaced some of the confectioner's sugar with corn starch while some have had good results using only half of the shorten called for. I also read that I shouldn't use the Crisco sticks, but the canister instead. When would I add the coloring?

MMF - I have seen many recipes but will most like use Darla's recipe over double boiler. I don't know if I can locate the dough hooks for the old oyster kitchen center mixer I use. Since I plan on separating the MMF in liquid stage to color it, can I use the regular blades until it comes together a bit then knead in the rest of the sugar? I have read that I butter extract added makes it taste like the rolled buttercream. Can I used butter vanilla emulsifier (or what ever it is called that is sitting on my table)?

I have a couple more little questions too. Please forgive me, I am a hobby baker because I worked fulltime and went to school fulltime. This is my first wedding cake and, even though they aren't paying for it, I don't want to screw it up.

I thought with the fact that the decorations are minimal a 2" difference in pan sizes would look better, so I am using 14" thru 6". Five tiers... wow! Location is 2 hours or so from my house. I want to stack the bottom two and the top two to travel. What do you think? Should I use all shortening and no butter in my buttercream so it will be stable. Wedding at 4pm, set up about 2pm, leave house at 11:30am. It will be out awhile but it is supposed to be about 12 degrees outside.

She doesn't care about filling and whatnot. She has given me no taste preferences. I know - she is very easy to please... not picky at all. She doesn't even care what I looks like, but I showed her my thoughts. Anyway, I plan on all cakes being white. My fillings are chocolate buttercream and ganache (from Toba) - cake spritzed with Amaretto; vanilla pastry cream - cake spritzed with orange liqueur; and lemon curd with raspberry jam spread on cake first... in that order from the bottom up. Don't know what to do with the other two tiers. I plan to torte the cake. What are your thoughts.

I thank you all in advance for any input you want to give. Sorry for such a long post but I still feel new at all this cake stuff since I do one every few months. Any other tips would be nice! Oh, cake is for this Saturday and I think I should make RBC or MMF tomorrow or Wednesday so it can meld together. Sorry for the last minute during holidays... I didn't think I would have this many issues.

Thanks, Joanne
post #2 of 4

as far as delivery--think about the weight -- the 14 and 12 will be most heavy--especially with some of those great fillings--i'd leave the 14 and 12 separate unless you have help that you trust to help you carry them and to deliver--they are not impossible to carry--but boxing the cakes is very important to me--makes delivery easier--

 

i would not use my home mixer much to make fondant--they are usually not strong enough--maybe for just the lightest part of the mixing--but even with the dough hooks i would not subject my home use mixer to that kind of load--

 

sure you can incorporate the coloring at any time--

 

i prefer the taste of butter to shortening in my icings so i would not use any shortening if it was me--but to get the whitest buttercream yes shortening is best for that--i talk my brides into slightly off white for the better taste--

 

you can flavor rolled buttercream with just about any flavoring imaginable--

 

i would recommend that you test both the fondant and the rbc to see which one you like best--rbc is not often used for this type of application--it can tear and stretch easily--for success you might want to freeze them before applying them--

 

for a better tasting fondant i often use flavored oil to zip it up 

 

hope you have a very successful cake!

the only way to see the rainbow is to look through the rain

 

Reply
the only way to see the rainbow is to look through the rain

 

Reply
post #3 of 4
Thread Starter 

K8 - Thank you for your reply.  I am so sorry that it took me so long to let you know how much I appreciated your advice.  I did take it to heart.  And it proved to be most valuable!

 

I took your advice about not stacking.  Delivery was so simple that way.  I was able to carry each tier into the venue by myself and they stacked without a hitch (basically).  They traveled better in the van too.  I just put down my middle seats, laid a rubber-lined blanket in the car (rubber-side up to provide non-slip surface) and put the cakes in.  Of course, I turned the air on the back and the heat on in the front. No sweat!

 

Since the weather wasn't hot, I took your advice and stuck to the butter in the icing - especially since it calls for half and half.  Worked like a charm and tasted great!

 

I ended up just going with the fondant.  Mainly because it seemed easier.  I had never made my own MMF before.  My daughter and I stirred it by hand and kneaded in the bowls.  It made for a easy process and the fondant turned out great.  I will never buy the stuff from a store again!  I used the butter emulsion in it and it tasted great - almost like a candy corn.  Of course, I had to make a few extra batches because of coloring issues.  It was easier to mix in in the liquid state. 

 

So, I must again thank you for your advice!  Here is a picture of the finished product.

 

post #4 of 4

awesome--you're so welcome--glad i could be of help--

 

kind of art deco meets victorian bling--you did a great job--how nice to have your daughter to help out--mine does too--

 

brava!

the only way to see the rainbow is to look through the rain

 

Reply
the only way to see the rainbow is to look through the rain

 

Reply
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Cake Decorating
Cake Central › Cake Forums › Cake Talk › Cake Decorating › Small scale RBC vs. MMF