Critique group member: I'm thinking your runout was too watery. The hat is adorable is it fondant?

critique group member: I think he's pretty cute! What a clever use of your cutter! My only suggestion would be to perhaps outline his face so that his pointy elf ears are more noticable.

Critique group member: The glossy and mat finishes are throwing me off abit, but his face is adorable. The coloring is nice, but it would have been cleaner if you had less cookie edges, otherwise I am saving him as an idea for a later date.

Oh this is so cute! :D Love it!

Critique Group Member: I can't add any critiques to what our other group members have mentioned. Overall it is soooo adorable. Thanks for sharing the tip of using an icecream cookie cutter.

Critique group member: Hi, Practiceandpatience, I think it is a very creative use of a cookie cutter; he is adorable, lots of details and I like he has some texture to him. The only additional comment I would make is perhaps next time cut down the excess dough on the cookie before baking; just a personal opinion but I think it looks better the less cookie you see. Great work yet again!

critique group member: What a great use for that cookie cutter....clever! I think he's cute, but I am finding his face to be too shiny. The green of the hat seems "duller" and I think his face woiuld look better like that, although I am not sure how to achieve it. He might alos look good outlined in black. Then his pointy elf ears would be really pronounced and less cookie would show.

critique subgroup member: I just love your original idea on the cookie cutter! I,too, am finding his face a bit too shiny and I like the more dull appearence of the green- still, his face is just adorable!

critique group member. What a great idea for the use of this cutter. He is really cute. My only suggestions would be to have the face and hat cover more of the cookie or possibly cut the extra off. Maybe make his hat shiny like the rest of him. Great job!