I'm hoping someone can answer this question for me. For those of you who live in Indiana...are there any good cake supply stores in Indianapolis or surrounding areas? I would like to find a good place to buy boxes, cupcake inserts, the list goes on and on...
Any help would be so appreciated!

Googling "restaurant supply indianapolis" brings up a few different restaurant supply stores. For boxes and cupcake inserts I recommend buying online at: http://www.brpboxshop.com/

thanks for the website suggestion! And the other advice! I guess that should be the second part of my question...any good websites suggested for buying bulk supplies? There are so many out there! It is hard to know who has the best prices!

For most bulk ingredients and supplies you won't be able to beat the prices at restaurant supply stores. They usually don't sell fondant, but you can get fondant for below wholesale at GSA:

http://www.globalsugarart.com/cat.php?cid=799

Go to www.countrykitchensa.com I love them.

There's a cake shop. I can't think of the name. Something about Bee's on the West side. You take the exit to the Indianapolis race track. Can someone else tell her the name? I don't live in Indy anymore - so I don't shop there anymore. I never purchased boxes there or anything - but when you need things, it's always nice to know of local shops.

There we go! I was going to call it Aunt B's. But I'm glad that you knew the name of the place for the OP!

You can get boxes and paper products from Cash & Carry Paper. Their prices on boxes and circles are really good.

You will LUV Ms. B's supply! Marsha (owner) has done cakes for YEARS and is my go-to person when I have a problem. She has two HUGE rooms of inventory. If she doesnt' have it, you probably don't need it!