Hi!
I use Toba's glace icing for my sugar cookies and up until now I've only received praise about them.
I'm making a cake and butterfly cookies for my friend's little girl's 5th birthday. It's all a gift- I'm a hobby baker.
My friend recently asked me why my white cookies taste better than the colored ones. At first I was surprised because no one has ever asked me that, not even my husband or mom- who are very honest with their critiques. I was also hurt because I felt that I'm working hard for free and not being appreciated. I just figured if your getting free cake and cookies, you shouldn't complain.
But I decided to take her comment to heart- I made pink butterfly cookies and all white ones. My 5 year old wanted some- he put a pink one in his mouth- then wanted to spit it out! He tried a white one and stuck with it.
So I did my own taste test- at first I couldn't taste anything different!!! I keep trying and now I think I do- like a slight bitterness, but only when I try the icing alone- not with the cookie.
I used maybe 2 drops of americolor...the bottle wasn't that old- could that make a difference? does americolor go bad?
Am I going crazy??? Has this happened to anyone else? Maybe my taste buds are desensitized?
any help would be appreciated!!!
sorry i can't help too much. i did notice a slight difference in my cookie glaze flavor with LOTS of color added...like red. but with a little pink, i'm not sure. maybe add a little more flavor to counter the color taste.
Hi, thanks for replying.
I use clear vanilla to flavor, I always make it the same way, following the recipe.
The thing is I never noticed anything...i've been asking others and some have never noticed anything, but one friend did notice a difference between the white glace cookies and the colored one...but she said it's still tastes great- just a little different.
I've decided I'm not going to worry about it- I think it depends on each person's sense of taste.
Thanks
i did a test cookie once with heaps and heaps of red in the icing and i did notice a very very slight difference in flavour but i can't taste a difference in any of my other coloured icings
Be aware - Americolor can go bad, perhaps Wilton as well. I had some white around for a while, added it to icing and tested it. Bad idea. It might have also gotten warm with summer temp as usually I store them in a cool place. In general though, I love Americolor. It is known for tasting better than Wilton.
I also notice a bitter taste especially w/ black , red, & navy.
I use Wilton's brand.
I also notice a chemical taste w/ Wilton's vanillia extract.
I take my cookies to work for coworkers to taste there is only one gal that thinks they taste bitter.
I guess we have sensitive bitter buds.
I also notice a bitter taste especially w/ black , red, & navy.
I use Wilton's brand.
I also notice a chemical taste w/ Wilton's vanillia extract.
I take my cookies to work for coworkers to taste there is only one gal that thinks they taste bitter.
I guess we have sensitive bitter buds.
Yes, some of Wilton's colors do taste bitter, especially when used in large quantities. That's one of the many reasons why I use Americolor. None of their colors taste bitter and it takes much less color to achieve deep, dark shades.
Let you colors sit overnight to deepen. That way you need less. Also, ick on the Wilton clear vanilla. If it helps, I like and use Spices Etc's all-natural clear vanilla. PM me if you want the coupon code for a first time order. I love their products.
I hate making red cookies or really dark colours because yes they do have a bitter taste and have been told so myself. I use mostly Wilton pastes.
Although I have asked this question here too and someone suggested no-taste red by Wilton which unfortunately I have not found in Australia yet.
As for mixing dark colours overnite like TracyLH suggested I do this as well and it works a treat.
Quote by @%username% on %date%
%body%