Maybe the angel is holding a small harp (so the cookie is a side profile of the angel)
Maybe this would help
I think it's her hands and sleeve.
The addition of a harp would be cute.
I agree with the other post that a harp would look cute.
Wow--you guys are the best!! Husband too agrees it's a harp, but I'm not talented enough to do 3 dozen for 2nd graders. I'll think I'll go with the sleeves and a star--I'll try to post a pic when I'm done. THANK YOU THANK YOU
You could have her holding a gift, instead of a harp. As long as you can decorate it, you can make it whatever you want!