I had this same problem on the last cake I did. I used the Americolor Chocolate Brown to tint my fondant it was a weird pinkish color. I guess I should look for a different brown. I ended up painting with that gel and extract. I guess icing would be a bit different. Can you start with a chocolate icing and then darken it from there?
For my son's monkey birthday cake (see my photos), I ended up adding some melted chocolate and some cocoa to my buttercream until the chocolate flavor was right, but it still wasn't the right color. I added brown icing color to make up the difference. Good luck!
what i did was i made dark chocolate icing and then added some brown wilton color. i let the icing t sit for a day in the refrigerator and it ended up being intense brown.
Quote by @%username% on %date%
%body%