What do you think would impress a guy more, a shirt or other piece of clothing from a store he likes or home baked goods?

Depends on the guy. I know guys that aren't in to sweets, so for them they'd rather have clothing or something else.

I've also known guys that do like sweets but don't get them very often. I've got a guy friend that I take treats too when I go over to his house. I bake stuff for my office, so it isn't a problem to save a few cupcakes or cookies or what ever out for him.

Neither.. A huge 1.5 inch slab of ribeye. He'll light up like a Christmas tree.

If you know that the guy would be into both, I would go with the baked goods. It requires more thought and effort IMO. Nothing makes my boyfriend happier than when I make him a plate of brownies.

Yep, a delicious hearty meal would be something awesome.
It's safe if you would know what type of food he likes, T-shirts are pretty much common everyday gifts, IMO.

my hubby's weaknesses are fresh baked choc chip cookies and rib eye. and craft beer...

the key to a man's heart is thru his stomach!

If he's a 'nice guy' that you'd introduce to your parents, showing him you can bake is an example of what a fine wife you'd make..... hehe

My husband still has the t-shirts and other little gifts I gave him when we were dating 14 years ago...but he brags about my cooking to his coworkers, so probably either one would work.

Personally, I wouldn't give an expensive gift to a guy when the relationship is really new.

A whipped cream bikini.

cakeville !
You made me choke on my coffee!

It's true though, and don't forget the cherries!