I wanted to try to Whimsical Bakehouse Vanilla cupcake recipe for an upcoming order. Instead of making the CC's one recipe yielded enough for a 6 in round. It domed quite a bit on top, SO I sliced that off and gave it a taste. To me it taste like cornbread. Especially if you eat the crust part along with the cake.

This was the recipe:
1 3/4 cup plus 2 T cake flour
3/4 tsp salt
1 cup sugar
1/2 cup plus 2 1/2 tsp warmed milk (110 F)
2 large eggs
4 oz (1 stick of butter)
1/2 tsp pure vanilla extract
1 1/2 tsp baking powder.

I followed the instructions to a "t"

Any suggestions, on how I get a more vanilla tasting recipe, or have one they would like to share.

Also it did not seem as moist as my other cakes. It's not crumble or anything just not moist IMO.

I tried this recipe before and I didin't like it either. I thought it was too dry and not tasty. What I did was add more vanilla and a capfull of veg. oil. I also add the oil to the caramel cake recipe in the WBH book. I love butter cakes but some of them tend to be dry, to me the oil helps without making it gummy.

[/quote]Ah, another "followed it to a T" post that didn't turn out right! I'm not poking at ya .... I'm just a "until it looks right" cook/baker, and just notice how many threads needing advice start out with "followed it to a T". I view a recipe as "just a suggestion" on what goes in it and how long it cooks/bakes.

[/quote]

LOL I'm not a scratch baker (for cakes) either, and I just proved it to myself yet one more time But I really resisted just changing things up on this one, because I really thought it would be a good recipe.

Maybe it was bad Karma, as I put the cake in the oven, the customer called me that she needed to reduce the order, because she had less people coming than what she thought. I convinced her not too, and then I realized the cake was not even pink like she wanted , so it was a waste anyways.

Thanks for your comments, I did not know the tip with the oil. I will keep that in mind next time. I mostly do altered cake mixes too, so it looks like I might be back to my true and tested cake extender recipe.

I read somewhere about adding mayo to recipes and that is the secret to a moist cake. I've never tried it before, but I will probably try it for my next recipe. But yeah, that recipe seems to be too dry with only 2 eggs and 1 stick of butter.

Now, just out of curiosity, did you make sure to have all of your ingredients at room temp and your dry ingredients sifted?

good to know. Do you mind sharing your typical recipe?

I always use the reverse method when baking from scratch. You didn't post the directions, but if the recipe doesn't call for the reverse method I would try that. So you would put all dry ingredients first (flour, sugar, leavening, & salt). Then you would add the fat. Mix until it starts looking like pebbles (similar to when making biscuits or pie crust). Then add all of your liquids into your measuring cup and slowly add to the bowl while the mixer is running. Beat for a minute until it is all incorporated.

This method works like a charm for me. I use this method for white cakes too.

You could also try subbing buttermilk, yogurt, or sour cream for the milk.

I also made a yellow cake from scratch that tasted like cornbread. Researched and tried the recipe again. So I substituted the AP flour for cake flour and I also creamed the butter and sugar mixture longer. This resulted in a moist cake that was light and fluffy. And the cornbread taste was no longer there. HTH.

Change the technique:

1.
Sift cake flour with baking powder and salt.

2.
Cream butter and sugar until dissolved.
Add eggs one by one until absorbed.
Add vanilla [1 teaspoon]

3.
Fold in 1/3 dry ingredients, 1/2 milk,1/3 dry ingredients, 1/2 milk, then lastly 1/3 dry ingredients.

Once you have completed the second part - do not use the electric mixer again

Folding the last ingredients in by hand ensures that there is minimal gluten-developement that makes a cake dry and "cornbread" in texture ..

I have been having the same problem with mine thank you Auzzi for the suggestions