Do you like it? Which would you recommend?

Vinyl. I bought it for $2.00 a yard at Wal-Mart several months ago. Great product.

I tried using vinyl, it sucks IMO. I bought the blue Ateco mat. I highly recommend it. I always had sticking problems before I bought this.

I use the Wilton roll and cut mat. I like it / have no problems with it!

I do most everything on a huge green (rotary) mat that's intended for sewing...one side has squares & measurements imprinted...I guess it's for laying and cutting fabric...

I use the flip side...it's plain green.
I love this thing...nothing sticks to it.

I just measured it...it's 36" x 24" by Olfa, and I got it at Jo-Ann Fabrics.

I use wilton...it's my first mat and works pretty well for me. You just have to be careful when cutting with an exacto-knife, I have a few holes in mine now