I have a friend who is yearning for a fudge his mother used to make. She is now deceased and he is reminiscing about those times.

He describes it as a chocolate fudge that is dry and crumbly to the touch that just melts in your mouth upon contact with the tongue. He says that he remembers he stirring the pot off and on for 8-9 hours.

Does anyone know what this might be?

Paul

i would try the recipe off the Hershey can

Who has that much time anymore? I use the recipe on the back of most jars of Marshmallow Cream - store brand or Kraft - also uses chocolate chips, sugar, etc. Our family loves it and it doesn't take long to make.

I don't know about 8 or 9 hours, but stirring the fudge from the Hershey can recipe can sometimes feel like that. I think I usually cook/stir for about a half an hour, then cool the fudge as directed, then beat it some more before pouring into the pan. It's definitely at least an hour to an hour and a half process. The fudge is well worth it, though! Once you've gotten addicted to that kind of fudge, the marshmallow creme versions just don't stack up anymore (no offense to marshmallow creme fudge lovers, )

My dad made this fudge for years - it has always been a family favorite. Now that he's passed, one of my brothers and I compete for the "best fudge maker" title. It isn't an easy recipe, but a good candy thermometer makes it a lot easier to get it to turn out!

The old fashioned fudge is the ONLY fudge I will eat! The other fudge just isn't REAL fudge!

I agree, Hershey's all the way. Marshmallow fudge is nasty.

I made Gale Gand's fudge recipe today, with a candy thermometer. It tastes delicious and creamy, but it didn't firm up. It's almost like frosting. Where did I go wrong? Can I do anything to it to get it to firm up now? I can probably use it in frosting, but I'd like to make it into good fudge, if possible.
Here's the recipe:
http://www.foodnetwork.com/recipes/gale-gand/creamy-rich-walnut-fudge-recipe/index.html
Thanks for your advice.

8 - 9 hours??? really?

my brothers and sisters and i grew up making the fudge recipe from the herseys cocoa box. That was a special thing for us to do together. delicious. Gonna make me some this week after reading this thread. lol!!!

Thanks for your help. I did some research, and one source said to scrape the soft fudge into a saucepan, add water, and start the cooking process all over. I am buying a new candy thermometer before I do that, though.

I honestly have never heard of a fudge cooking that long. If you cook the mixture too long, it will crystalize and turn back to sugar consistency.

I understand your dilemma. It seems as every family has their fudge recipe that they like and they love. Is there any family members that you can talk to and try and narrow down some of the ingredients used? Example - some recipes use milk others use cream, etc. I am sure whatever recipe you try, your friend will truly appreciate.

I've checked both the Hershey's syrup and cocoa cans, and I couldn't find a fudge recipe. The Hersheys.com website seems to have only quick-cook or marshmallow fudge recipes.
Can someone please direct me to the Hershey's fudge recipe mentioned above?
Thanks.

Wow. That's quite a thermometer. I've had my old-fashioned one for decades. Guess it's time for a replacement.
Thanks for the information.

This is a slightly grainy fudge, like the old fashioned kind, but easier

Chocolate Fudge
1 cup sugar
1 small box chocolate pudding mix, NOT INSTANT
4 tsp instant coffee
1/2 cup evaporated milk
1 Tbs. butter

mix everything in a saucepan and bring to a boil. Boil for 4 minutes. Remove from heat and add :

1 cup chopped nuts

Beat until thickened. Pour into buttered pan Makes 1 1/2 lbs fudge

Back to thermometers for just a bit -

You can test your cooking thermometers by placing them in boiling water.
The temperature of boiling water is 212 degrees F and 100 degrees C. If your thermometer reads at these temps, it's still in working order.

Theresa

I agree, Marshmallow fudge - nasty. Hershey's all the way. Recipe, to the best of my knowledge (I do it off the top of my head, so correct if wrong)

3 cups sugar
2/3 cups cocoa
1 1/2 cup milk, ( i use canned and do 3/4 cup milk and 3/4 cup water)

Cook in saucepan on low heat, stirring constantly until it forms a soft ball in water, or reaches soft ball stage on thermometer. Remove from heat, add vanilla and pat of butter. Let cool a little and then beat the h--- out of it. when it loses its sheen, pour into well buttered pan.

Here is the recipe from the Hershey's website. My sister said it wasn't there or on the back of the can anymore but it is at least still on the website.

http://www.hersheys.com/recipes/5303/Rich-Cocoa-Fudge.aspx

it's the same as the one I posted above

that is the recipe we used . we used condensed milk (half milk , half water). I make a chocolate icing the same way for my cakes, (old fashion way also. You cook it on top of the stove to a certain consistency , poke holds in your cake layers and put the fudge icing on each layer. It is so good. My mama made it that way, My family loves for me to make it that way. I freeze the cake for a couple of days , before cutting into it. Makes it that much more wonderful. I cook the icing to a soft ball stage.

Has anyone ever tried this?

2-ingredient fudge, from canned frosting and chocolate chips.

Here's a webpage about it -

http://www.nancys-kitchen.com/fudge-recipe-variations.htm

Theresa

Thanks for all the help and advice. I couldn't salvage the first batch of fudge I made. It turned into chocolate pecan soup. I'm planning on trying the Hershey's recipe tomorrow.
I realize there's no exact time for these stages, but can someone provide some approximate times?
How long should it take for the fudge to reach the soft ball stage?
How long should it take for the mixture to cool down?
How long should the fudge be beaten?
It seeme like each of these stages took forever. Is that normal?
Thanks again.

The recipe we have always used for fudge (ours is a two toned one) has butter, sugar, evaporated milk, and marshmallow creme. It is cooked on the stove top until it boils, then cooked for another 5 or so mins. We then mix half with chocolate chips (nuts and rum can be added), pour that in the bottom and mix the other half with butterscotch chips and that is spread on top.

Batch #2--The Hershey's recipe (http://www.hersheys.com/recipes/5303/Rich-Cocoa-Fudge.aspx)

I followed the recipe PRECISELY as written.

The fudge was like chocolate pecan bubble gum at first, then it dried into a crumbly mass that wouldn't spread into pan. And so much of the stuff was stuck in the bottom of the saucepan.

What am I doing wrong? AGAIN?
Thanks.

cutthecake - when you have the fudge on the stove, you cook it until it reaches a soft ball stage. That means if you drop a little bit of the mixture in a glass of cool water it will form a ball. Some times it will flatten out when you add it to the water, but if you reach with your fingers and pick it up, you can roll it into a soft ball.

Once you take it off the heat, I let mine sit for about 3-4 minutes on a cool burner, then I start beating and mixing the candy. You will need to beat it consistently (I do sometimes set the spoon down for a second to give my arm a rest, but you have to keep mixing it). It is ready to pour when it thickens up and if you scrape the side of the pot you start to see it crusting on the side. Immediately pour it into a pan to set. It may take 20-30 minutes to firm enough to cut.

My Mom always told me never to make candy when it rains. Well I do anyway. I just turn up the heat in my house to take the moisture out of the air.

Hope this helps.

Thanks, cricket!
The Hershey's recipe says to let the pot of fudge cool down to 110*, which took about a half hour or so, before beating with the spoon. I used a candy thermometer, which I tested first so I know it was working properly.
It's a cold, dry day--no rain.
I watched and waited patiently and obediently during every stage of the fudge-making.
I'm so frustrated!

I do what cricket said. Let it sit a few minutes and stir then pour onto a buttered cookie sheet - what my dad always did. Sometimes he would add 1/4 cup of peanut butter instead of the butter. I have never been able to let it cool to 110 degrees or even stir it until it is no longer glossy. It becomes to thick to stir and it does become too crumbly to try and pour out.

I made this one last night, super easy and tasted great. I used premium Ghiradelli chocolate chips. You could switch up the flavoring and additions to it to meet whatever taste you are looking for.

http://www.womansday.com/Recipes/Candy-Cane-Chocolate-Fudge-Recipe