There has been alot of discussion about Magic Line vs. Fat Daddios but has anyone tried the Wilton Decorator Preferred. I bought 1 thinking it was Magic Line and didn't realize it was Wilton until after I got it home. It has the straight sides and square corners on the 9 x 13 pan I got. The cost appears to be similar to Magic Line on the sites I was pricing it.

Has anyone else tried these? Any opinions?

I have and I really can't tell any difference to my cakes compared to Fat Daddio's.

Al but 2 of my pans are Wilton Decorator Preferred. I can't tell the difference in between those and the 2 Magic Line pans I have. Nice straight sides and perfect corners. Works for me!

Toni Ann

I also have a couple that are - they are good pans as far as my opinion goes. I don't have a preference between any of the 3

Thanks! I appreciate the input. I'm glad they're working for you guys and I may go ahead and buy some more.

Wilton Decorator preferred is the only brand of pans I own.

I also only use wilton..

I have some and they're certainly better than the regular Wilton line. Magic Line really is the gold standard in pans, though, and you'll never regret buying good tools.

Wilton for me. I can not get anything else in my area to try something and well Wilton works just fine for me. If it ain't broke don't fix it. So, I will stick with Wilton.