Why don't we all just mail it to each other like the girls in " The Sisterhood Of The Traveling Pants".
That would be so much fun! I'm in if anyone wants to start! You send the cookie cutter out to the first person, you have 1-2 weeks to make your cookies, post your picture and send the cutter off to the next person!
Sweet Results- what an awesome idea- I'd be in!!!!! 
Oh- and I think if you turn it sideways and get rid of the bottom thingy sticking out it could be a "thumbs up"...but I don't know what it was intended to be originally...
I believe it is a picture of a young girl, embracing life and in love for the first time, eating a slice of pie while sitting on the riverbank.
Oh, wait a minute. That was my answer for my last appointment with the shrink...
ROTFLMAO 
I believe it is a picture of a young girl, embracing life and in love for the first time, eating a slice of pie while sitting on the riverbank.
Oh, wait a minute. That was my answer for my last appointment with the shrink...
ROTFLMAO
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
I'm with a few others on this one. If you turn it over it looks like a cowboy hat.
Actually it looks like a Wilton cookie cutter. Back when they put them in a package. Let me explain: They sold cutter sets that had the cutter eyes and icing colors for certain characters. I have a Bob the Builder. The other day I could not figure it out but after I sat it down my grandson came in and told me what cutter it was. I had made cookies for him with that cutter. Look in an old Wilton catalog and see what you can find.
YAAAAAY!!!! Mystery solved!!!!!! Thanks, doescakestoo!! Tell your grandson what a smart boy he is!!
Love the traveling idea!
Here's a thought....
BTW - I Googled the Bob the Builder cookie cutter and the indentations on the bottom don't match up. 
Bob is more round on the bottom...
So keep guessing ladies!!!
Looks a lot like a bowler hat if you turn it upside down?
I just read through all the posts here...quite interesting. My first thought was that it was a Crock Pot. But then I thought to myself..1)a Crock Pot is flat on the bottom, and 2) who would want a Crock Pot cookie (maybe a chef or caterer?!). So I don't actually think that's it, but that was my first thought...I know, I'm no help Jodie
It's mr. magoo. I know it is. fer reals!!! dang nope!! not mr. magoo. How bout betty boop and the thingees on the sides are the handle bars for holding the cutter (could be a home fabricated one)
and yer sposed to lop off the "horns" as it were. LOL
i LOVE the traveling idea. i'm in too. i've done the cookie culb thing online, but i also thought it would be more interesting if everyone used the same cutter to see just how different everyone's imagination's were.
i'm in i'm in i'm in!!!
Maybe an acorn? Still not convinced, but this is an acorn cutter I have:
Quote by @%username% on %date%
%body%