Hi CC family. I need help making a decision. I baked a chocolate cake yesterday and it is currently in my freezer. I will finish filling and frosting it for my daughter's school's dessert contest. I am torn between the two:

cookies and cream filling, frosted white with oreo crumbs around the outside. I also want to halfway dip oreos into white candy melts and arrange them on the top.

OR

filled with peanut butter mousse and iced with the chocolate peanut butter fudge frosting from this site, with reese cup decorations.

my co-worker says that sounds too peanut buttery. but I don't know about that. Anyways, help me figure out which way to go! Thanks!

My vote is for the peanut butter!! I don't think there's any such thing as too much peanut butter!

well that's one pb, oreo zero...any others?

sorry to even it out but I say Oreo. I love cookies and cream.

I'm tipping the scales...Oreo!

I say go for the oreo as you may have some kids allergic to pbutter

I do an oreo cookies n cream filling and people always go nuts for it! Also you don't want to spark any allergies as another post mentioned. My Sister-in-law is DEATHLY allergic to nuts and legumes.

Thank you all for your help! When I ran it past my grandmother she said the same thing about people with nut allergies....that has definitely helped me make the decision! Oreo it is