I wanted to make MacsMom's Orange Dreamsicle cake for my dad for Father's day so I got on CC to find the recipe and I found at least 3 versions. I hate to PM her because I'm sure she spends hours replying to messages. Does anyone know which one is her recipe or which one is best? Thanks so much!

RECIPE NUMBER 1
Orange Dreamsicle - MacsMom
2 boxes white cake mix
2 c melted orange sherbet
2/3 c OJ or diet orange soda (soda suggested by cinderspritzer: "I added ... diet sunkist soda.... and it tastes FREAKING AWESOME!!!")
2 c flour
2 c sugar
3 (6oz) orange creamsicle yogurt
6 eggs
1/4 c oil
1 T orange extract
*Perhaps some food coloring


RECIPE NUMBER 2
Orange Dreamsicle - MacsMom
2 boxes white cake mix
2 c melted orange sherbet
2/3 c OJ or diet orange soda (soda suggested by cinderspritzer: "I added ... diet sunkist soda.... and it tastes FREAKING AWESOME!!!")
2 c flour
1-3/4 c sugar
1-1/2 tsp salt
1/2 tsp baking soda (modified to add baking soda 3/10/10)
2 c sour cream
9 egg whites
1/4 c oil
1 T orange extract
*Perhaps some food coloring


RECIPE NUMBER 3
Orange creamsicle by MacsMom
Ingredients
Cake:
1 box white cake mix
2 c melted orange sherbet
1 small pkg vanilla instant pudding
2 containers (6 oz) Yoplait orange creamsicle yogurt
3 eggs
2 t orange extract
Filling:
2 pkgs instant vanilla pudding
1/2 c water
14 oz sweetened condensed milk (I used fat-free)
orange food coloring
1 t orange extract
2 c Cool Whip

I'm confused too. Where did you find those three? I've only seen the first one. You should definetely pm her but if you don't then go to the gourmet flavor thread in the cake ideas forum and ask there. She's always there to help. Someone there will answer for you if she doesn't.

Thanks, Yummy. Guess I will see if she can help me out. I just hate to bother her

yes I have noticed the one using soda & one without both from Macsmom. I tried recipe #3 & it was incredible, super moist & flavorful and it's the one I will use from now on.

I've used recipe #1 and I loved it. Never seen the other two.

this is the one I use & it's awesome-
http://cakecentral.com/recipes/4643/orange-creamsicle
it includes the filling recipe which completes the creamsicle flavor