Could you tell me what type of gp/fondant that you used & how thin you rolled it? Also the settings you used on your Cricut?
I've only been successful with large, simple cut-outs (nothing as intricate as yours). I'm using fondant with tylose. I rolled to all different thicknesses on my pasta machine. I've removed all the tackiness from my mat & use a thin film of Crisco. I also use the deep housing blade. I've tried to let the gp dry @ different times on the mat as well. When I try the intricate designs or letters, the blade cuts well at first, then it seems to drag the gumpaste.