Critique Subgroup Member: What a beautiful job on this cake! Your detail work is terrific and i love the wood color. The strings could be tighter, but it really doesn't detract from this cake! Great job!!

critique group member: Nice work!! The color is perfect and the handle is awesome. To me, the bottom seems off a little bit, not sure what it is though, but this is really nice!!

Critique group member: Wow this is amazing! All the details look fabulous espcially "swirled" part at the top.

critique subgroup member" What a great cake. The wood effect looks fabulous and I love all of the details. I think the strings would look better taut as well, but they look good as is. I like how you made a music sheet to incorporate your message. Overall this is exceptional. Great job.

Critique Subgroup Member. Coming in 12th, there's not much to add. I agree with the thoughts on the stout shape and the strings. I also agree with the color and wood grain--good job. I like the attention to details on the side of the cake.

i love the richness of the wood colour, really shines! Your detailed carving is amazing!

Critique Subgroup Member: I think you did a fantastic job! The colour is perfect! Your strings look great! It looks very life like! No critiques here!

Critique Group Member: Wow! Very detailed work on the wood and accents. Its sculpted beautifully with all the curves and lines. The only critique I can give is to make the stings finer. Congratulations - I'll be he loved it!

critique subgroup member: beautiful job! the wood grain is great and the detailing is fantastic. the proportions on the body seem a bit off, a little thick and a bit short, but not sure if correct proportions are ever completely possible in cake. I also think the strings needed to be taut. overall very good work!

Critique Subgroup Member: What an excellent job you did on this! It's perfectly lovely and very impressive! Congratulations and I'm sure your son just loved it!

Critique subgroup member: You really managed getting the wood just right and the music shet is a nice touch. Too bad about the strings. I think I would have looked at floral wire for some help.

critique subgroup member: The wood color and grain is awesome, and you've got terriffic detail. The only thing I think could be improved a little is the strings, I think they'd look better taut. But I think it's an awesome cake. :D