Critique Group Member: Glad to see you didn't go with the 'standard' football cake. The design is very creative - I love those footballs in the corners, nice touch. Your logos are perfect. Not sure about the face guards - I think these could have been a simple grid (grey or black). This cake is gonna be a huge hit at the party. Being a New Yorker I have to cheer for the underdog!!

Critique Group Member: I,too, am so happy to see a different kind of football cake for a change. :) I really like the football edges and the grassy bordering. Your helmets look amazing but I have to agree that the grid may have looked better so that it didn't turn out so solid in some areas. Still, it is an awesome cake- more original than the typical. Great job!

Critique Group Member: Great job on this cake and I like the little footballs in the corner!! I'm gonna agree with Snowhoe and Sylly about the face guards. Also, are the roman numerals slanted or is it just the picture?? I really like this though, save me a slice!! :D

Critique subgroup member: Boy your frosting is smooth! I think I would have made the grass shorter to reflect the field more. And I'm not sure of the face masks. Is the Super Bowl logo a tiny bit crooked or is it the picture? Nice touch on the footballs on the end quarters.

critique subgroup member: great way to add the helmets!! they look great! have to agree the face mask is a bit overdone?? but they look great. For me, the green is a bit dark, but again, that is just me. overall, very well done. PS: love the little footballs! great addition!

Critique group member: Very nice design! I agree that the helmets facemask looks a litte odd and the logo also looks crooked.