critique group member. I love the border on this cake i think it fits really well. You did a fantastic job on the logos.I only see a few minor dimples in the white on the football and I think the outline on the logos could be a bit straighter. I really like how smooth the football is, I know that is hard on this cake (i've done it) with it awkward shape and all. Great work!
Wow you all, those are some great critiques. Thanks! I'm glad you mentioned the top border. I didn't realize how sloppy it was on the right side. That challenges me to do better next time. :D
Critique group member: Very nice! I love the border and the colors! Like the others said I see the dimples on the football but overall tthis is an amazing cake!
Thank you! The football and the field are both white cakes. Normally I prefer to use fondant to make the stripes on the football but I was experimenting with RI this time.
Critique Group Member: the football looks great, a couple dimples in the white stripes but otherwise it is perfectly smooth. your bottom border looks flawless. this is a great design and all f your RI work really paid off it is a great look. It has enough detail without being too much congratulations
critique subgroup member: WOW...the football is bc? It is so smooth. I LOVE that rope border and the green is the perfect color. Looks like there are a few dents or fingerprints the white parts of the football and some of the numbers are inconsistent, but those are truly picky little things. You did a great job on this cake!
Critique subgroup member: Truly a well done composition. Everything is done beautifully. Just a couple of issues the others mentioned and a little issue with the inconsisent top border other then that - heck great cake and if it weren't for the critique group I would never have picked that up!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Critique Subgroup Member: The football bc is very smooth...and yet it looks like just a hint of texture, possibly from a paper towel. I think that makes it look like the texture on real footballs. The smooth rope border is a great accent to the rest of the design.
Critique Group Member: Great cake. Love that border! Is it fondant? Love all the elements of this cake--the grass, the colors. The only thing I would change is to put the cake on a bigger board.
Critique Group Member: I just love how you took a cake that has been done many times and made it look so much more with your own little touches- the border really added some flair to it- I love the brown as it ties in with the ball. Besides the already mentioned dimples, it's awesome. The writing on it reminds me of a signed ball, that's pretty cool. Your smoothness on the sides looks fantastic and the grass is great.The fact that you used RI instead of fondant is pretty impressive! excellent!! :D
critique subgroup member: Great Cake!! I love the added detail of the team names and logos, adds extra color and dimension! Football is great, and I too see a bit of texture added??? great touch! I think the white strips could have been a bit thinner, and for me, the green is a bit dark, for me dark colors tend to be not as appetizing. (just me) The bottom rope border is flawless!!, couple of inconsistencies on the top but not sure how anyone can do those perfectly!! overall wonderful job!!!
critique group member: Very, very nice! The rope border is awesome. Very smooth bc. Love the texture of the grass. My only critique is that the big stripes across the ball are not completely smooth. Overall presentation is great!
critique group member. I love the border on this cake i think it fits really well. You did a fantastic job on the logos.I only see a few minor dimples in the white on the football and I think the outline on the logos could be a bit straighter. I really like how smooth the football is, I know that is hard on this cake (i've done it) with it awkward shape and all. Great work!
Wow you all, those are some great critiques. Thanks! I'm glad you mentioned the top border. I didn't realize how sloppy it was on the right side. That challenges me to do better next time. :D
Looks great! Is the football cake or rice crispies? The frosting on the ball is awesome!
Critique group member: Very nice! I love the border and the colors! Like the others said I see the dimples on the football but overall tthis is an amazing cake!
Thank you! The football and the field are both white cakes. Normally I prefer to use fondant to make the stripes on the football but I was experimenting with RI this time.
Critique Group Member: I also meant to add that all critiques are welcome.
Critique Group Member: the football looks great, a couple dimples in the white stripes but otherwise it is perfectly smooth. your bottom border looks flawless. this is a great design and all f your RI work really paid off it is a great look. It has enough detail without being too much congratulations
critique subgroup member: WOW...the football is bc? It is so smooth. I LOVE that rope border and the green is the perfect color. Looks like there are a few dents or fingerprints the white parts of the football and some of the numbers are inconsistent, but those are truly picky little things. You did a great job on this cake!
Critique subgroup member: Truly a well done composition. Everything is done beautifully. Just a couple of issues the others mentioned and a little issue with the inconsisent top border other then that - heck great cake and if it weren't for the critique group I would never have picked that up!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Critique Subgroup Member: The football bc is very smooth...and yet it looks like just a hint of texture, possibly from a paper towel. I think that makes it look like the texture on real footballs. The smooth rope border is a great accent to the rest of the design.
Critique Group Member: Great cake. Love that border! Is it fondant? Love all the elements of this cake--the grass, the colors. The only thing I would change is to put the cake on a bigger board.
Critique Group Member: I just love how you took a cake that has been done many times and made it look so much more with your own little touches- the border really added some flair to it- I love the brown as it ties in with the ball. Besides the already mentioned dimples, it's awesome. The writing on it reminds me of a signed ball, that's pretty cool. Your smoothness on the sides looks fantastic and the grass is great.The fact that you used RI instead of fondant is pretty impressive! excellent!! :D
critique subgroup member: Great Cake!! I love the added detail of the team names and logos, adds extra color and dimension! Football is great, and I too see a bit of texture added??? great touch! I think the white strips could have been a bit thinner, and for me, the green is a bit dark, for me dark colors tend to be not as appetizing. (just me) The bottom rope border is flawless!!, couple of inconsistencies on the top but not sure how anyone can do those perfectly!! overall wonderful job!!!
critique group member: Very, very nice! The rope border is awesome. Very smooth bc. Love the texture of the grass. My only critique is that the big stripes across the ball are not completely smooth. Overall presentation is great!