I spent several hours looking over recipes, tips and ideas shared on how to make a orange creamsicle cake. I finally chose a recipe which is in the oven now. ALL OVER THE OVEN. It overflowed the pans and is sinking in the middle.
I used this recipe:
2 boxes White Cake Mix
2 cups melted Orange Sherbet
2/3 cup diet orange soda
2 cups flour
2 cups sugar
3 orange creamsicle yogurt
1/4 cup oil
1 T orange extract
I'm not sure where I went wrong, but if anyone out there knows which recipe actually works, I'd appreciate it if you would share it.
I have 2 Duncan Hines Orange Supreme Cake Mixes and some white mixes. I have the ingredients to make a cake from scratch as well.
Don't have enough yogurt to retry the recipe though.
I made a scratch recipe and replaced some of the liquid with orange soda, added orange zest and Lorann orange oil. I made a melted vanilla ice cream American buttercream too. It was a huge hit. I also added a bit of orange food coloring, to the cake, too.
Rosegin, are you willing to share the recipe? I love orange creamsicle!
AI used the recipe from Sweetapolita's blog. It's her triple lemon blueberry cake recipe, minus the blueberries and lemon.
Thanks. I'll look it up!