Why do some buttercreams make throat scratchy temporarily?

Is it too much sugar?

Do you know what butter creams are making your throat scratchy? It sounds like an mild allergic reaction, find out what the ingredients are and avoid them!
Scratchy throat could be the beginning of a serious allergic reaction, better to find the culprit and avoid it.

its sugarshacks recipe which ive used for several years...im making it in a 20qt mixer now which means ive quadrupled it, but i put extra pwdered sugar in it and i think that's the cuase. swhen i make it in my reg kitchenaid i dont get that problem

ive had certain store bought cakes that give me the same scratchy throat fillign

My husband complains about his throat being scratchy whenever I make BC recipes with a lot of powdered sugar, like Indy's recipe. When I make an IMBC or Charlotte's recipe, he doesn't complain about it. He says it's "harsh and scratchy."

Sometimes too much sugar can make your throat tingle but it should go away with a drink or two. If it persists, you should check for allergies.

Are you using some kind of extract-almond would mean a reaction to tree nuts?

hmmm sounds allergy related to me too.

hey everyone!

i am not allergic to nuts and have almond all the time with no reaction. the scratchiness/irritation disappears after a few seconds, taht's why im thinking it the sugar like kitgrl suggested.

Like I said, you can develop allergies any time in your life. Unless you were tested say last week, you do not know for sure. Like I also said, a slight scratchiness that goes away does not mean it is life threatening, just that it is there.