Baking Science Folks! Effects Of Hi-Ratio Cake Flour?!
Baking By SugarFiend Updated 25 Jul 2011 , 3:21pm by FullHouse
This is a new one. I got a 50lb bag of Velvetex cake flour from a restaurant supplier. (Boy, did I underestimate the size, but that's another story!)
Having never heard of the brand (and also because it was so cheap, I wondered if it's a crappy brand), I googled it and find that it's hi-ratio. "Good for high sugar, high fat baking."
Is anyone out there familiar with this brand, or with hi-ratio cake flour in general? I baked a cake yesterday with unexpected results, so I wonder if my cake flour had anything to do with it.
Or would anyone care to offer some theories as to how it MIGHT affect my recipes, if nothing else? With such a huge bag of flour, it would be nice to know what I bought and how it will behave - cuz it's gonna be making a LOT of cakes.
Thank you!
Post your recipe.
I would say the results you got is from the hi-ratio cake flour, especially if you have used the recipe with other cake flour and got different results. I got my hands on some too and I couldn't believe the rise when I used it. My cupcakes over flowed out of the pan. I had to put in less batter.
It was Rebecca Rather's White on White buttermilk, if you're familiar with it. I can post it in a bit if not.
It was the first time I made the recipe - but crazy rising was my issue, too. It was rising by the time I made my second buttermilk addition!
oh wow the things you learn from cc!! This is interesting
What exactly is hi-ratio flour? I understand hi-ratio shortening (with the emulsifiers) but I've never heard of hi-ratio flour.
What exactly is hi-ratio flour? I understand hi-ratio shortening (with the emulsifiers) but I've never heard of hi-ratio flour.
Uhhhhh, yeah, I really don't know! I just know that I had to go out and buy a big ol' ginormous tub to put my bag of it in. Of course, I threw the bag away, so I don't know what it said... 
And gildee, I don't know what to tell you about where to get it. I got it from a local restaurant supplier, so maybe you could find it at a bakery supplier or restaurant supplier?
And LindaF144a, here's the recipe I used, Rebecca Rather's White on White Buttermilk cake:
Cake:
1 1/2 cups unsalted butter, at room temperature
2 1/3 cups sugar
3 large egg whites
2 tsp. vanilla extract
3 cups cake flour
3/4 tsp. baking soda
3/4 tsp. salt
1 1/2 tsp. baking powder
1 1/2 cups buttermilk
Creaming method, then adding eggs and vanilla, then alternating dry with wet ingredients. So nothing weird there. My buttermilk was on the cold side, though.
I had never made the recipe before, so I'm not sure what would have normally happened. I've been going over it in my head all day to try to think what went wrong.
I've made this recipe and found it to be too dense for my liking. The flavor is divine, though.
I've only used Velvetex for years. It's excellent.
Leah,
I don't mean to ask for a recipe. But when using the high-ratio cake flour did you do anything to tweak the recipe for better results? I always get such a light cupcake when I use the high-ration cake flour. It overflows in one big mushroom, is crumbly and falls apart.
I can use a high-ratio cake flour, but i use a local brand. It is one of the last flour mills here in my area. I would love to say that I use local products, but cannot figure out how to control the beast of high-ratio cake flour besides less batter and I don't like the look of that cupcake either.
So would hi-ratio flour be a direct substitution for the flour in the recipe? Or would you have to change the amounts? And in a recipe that calls for both AP and cake flour, which would you sub with hi-ratio. Or is it really not this simple and more scientific than all this?
My experience has been that there is a huge difference between hi-ratio cake flour and regular cake flour. Thus the reason why I asked Leah the question I did. IMO, you can substitute it, but you will get different results depending on the recipe.
Just to give an update... I did try this recipe again (with hi-ratio cake flour) with a few changes in an attempt to slow down the near-explosive rise.
Basically, I just used everything straight from the fridge (eggs, butter, buttermilk) rather than bringing them to room temp as I normally would. I even went so far as chiling my mixing bowl and paddle. Also, I did the dry/wet combining as quickly as I dared.
My results were MUCH better. Unfortunately, I skimped a little too much on the mixing, because I had some ill-mixed batter at the bottom. So then my pans weren't quite as full as I would have liked (and my cakes not as tall). I think I sacrificed some structure with my short mixing too, because I had some top edge shrinkage as they cooled. (Is this actually a contributor to shrinkage? Am I correct in thinking I didn't develop the gluten enough to give it the structure to withstand cooling?)
But I slowed the rise so that the cakes didn't explode out of the pans! They rose pretty levelly, actually. So the cake had good texture, flavor, and moistness. It seemed more fragile than WASC cakes, though - more prone to breakage while maneuvering it from pan to rack to cake board. Next time I'll take a minute for one last good bowl scrapedown and extend my mix time by a hair, and I think it will be perfect.
Just thought this might be helpful... 
(Edited to fix a few typos...!)
Missed this thead the first time. As to the original question here is why it would impact your recipe.
Hi-ratio flour is used in cakes that have a high ratio of sugar and liquid to flour. Hi ratio flour is able to absorb more water, and thus it is able to absorb more sugar.
One way you can tell the impact of hi-ratio flour is that it can still produce thick case batters with high amounts of liquid and sugar. The batter would otherwise be thin and liquidy if the same amount of non-hi ratio flour was used.
In terms of the final product hi ratio cake recipes produce cakes that are light, moist and have a tender crumb. In addition they also have a higher volume which would explain the rise you saw in your original recipe.
Missed this thead the first time. As to the original question here is why it would impact your recipe.
Hi-ratio flour is used in cakes that have a high ratio of sugar and liquid to flour. Hi ratio flour is able to absorb more water, and thus it is able to absorb more sugar.
One way you can tell the impact of hi-ratio flour is that it can still produce thick case batters with high amounts of liquid and sugar. The batter would otherwise be thin and liquidy if the same amount of non-hi ratio flour was used.
In terms of the final product hi ratio cake recipes produce cakes that are light, moist and have a tender crumb. In addition they also have a higher volume which would explain the rise you saw in your original recipe.
That's interesting... Are you aware if recipes are written or adapted specifically for hi-ratio flour? The one I posted doesn't seem to have particularly high ratio of sugar or liquids to flour - but I don't have that science knowledge. I did notice my batter was quite thick, though.
Is hi-ratio cake flour better suited to a different mixing method than traditional creaming? Are higher liquid and sugar amounts better to use? Or would it be better to just cut back on the flour?
This has SO gotten my scientific brain working overtime. I MUST go out and get a baking science book or three. I've heard The Joy of Baking is pretty good - anyone else have other recommendations? Then again, is the topic of hi-ratio cake flours even covered?
Thanks to everyone for your input!
No idea why my post went across three times... 
Again, not sure why this post came across three times...
Missed this thead the first time. As to the original question here is why it would impact your recipe.
Hi-ratio flour is used in cakes that have a high ratio of sugar and liquid to flour. Hi ratio flour is able to absorb more water, and thus it is able to absorb more sugar.
One way you can tell the impact of hi-ratio flour is that it can still produce thick case batters with high amounts of liquid and sugar. The batter would otherwise be thin and liquidy if the same amount of non-hi ratio flour was used.
In terms of the final product hi ratio cake recipes produce cakes that are light, moist and have a tender crumb. In addition they also have a higher volume which would explain the rise you saw in your original recipe.
That's interesting... Are you aware if recipes are written or adapted specifically for hi-ratio flour? The one I posted doesn't seem to have particularly high ratio of sugar or liquids to flour - but I don't have that science knowledge. I did notice my batter was quite thick, though.
Is hi-ratio cake flour better suited to a different mixing method than traditional creaming? Are higher liquid and sugar amounts better to use? Or would it be better to just cut back on the flour?
This has SO gotten my scientific brain working overtime. I MUST go out and get a baking science book or three. I've heard The Joy of Baking is pretty good - anyone else have other recommendations? Then again, is the topic of hi-ratio cake flours even covered?
Thanks to everyone for your input!
While I have not tried it, the answer to your question above is yes. Most professionals do not use the creaming method in the kitchen for cakes. It is too time consuming. Instead they use what used to be called the hi-ratio method, or it may still be called that. Anyway, it is like the reverse creaming method. It has been awhile since I read about it, but I believe it is in the book Professional Baking by Wayne Goselin. I may be off on the spelling of the last name.
Also, the recipe you posted is considered a hi-ratio recipe. The weight of the sugar is higher than the weight of the flour by 132%. And it does call for cake flour.
I also use hi-ratio cake flour. I forgot about this discussion, or I would have posted it. I took a similar recipe and made by altering the eggs. First I used all egg yolks, then all egg whites, then the equivalent in weight of whole eggs. The one that exploded the most is the all egg white recipe, which I notice in your recipe. Egg whites have some awesome leavening power, which is how you get a light delicious angel food cake.
Switch out your eggs and see what happens.
Thank you LindaF144a, I will go and try to find that book. And I'm glad to hear that recipe is hi-ratio, because it's my front-runner in my quest for a good white cake recipe. Not to mention the fact that I have 50 lbs. of hi-ratio flour to go through!
I'll also try switching the eggs, too. That's kinda funny, the two things I rarely have a shortage of in this house: cake flour and eggs. (My neighbor has chickens and brings me fresh eggs sometimes 2 or 3 dozen at a time.)
Hm, now if he'd just get a couple of cows! 
Fresh eggs will have even more leavening power. And it is advisable to weigh them seeing how you are probably getting all sorts of eggs in all sorts of different sizes. That could definitely be a factor, especially in a recipe with all egg whites.
I didn't use the eggs he gives me for baking for the longest time for that very reason. Until the day I had that "DUH... weigh the eggs!" moment.
Hi-ratio flour can be used in recipes with a higher liquid content than for example, a sponge cake. As the grains of this flour are finer than usual flour, it allows for better absorption of liquids and so therefore if you are substituting it for biscuit/cake or bakers flour (larger grains, higher gluten content), you would naturally add more liquid to your recipe.
Hi-ratio flour can be used in recipes with a higher liquid content than for example, a sponge cake. As the grains of this flour are finer than usual flour, it allows for better absorption of liquids and so therefore if you are substituting it for biscuit/cake or bakers flour (larger grains, higher gluten content), you would naturally add more liquid to your recipe.
Actually it has nothing to do with the finer grain and everything to do with the type of wheat used. It is made with a softer red winter wheat that has a lower protein count, a lower ash count and a higher starch count. And not all cake flours are alike. The Swans Down available at most grocery stores is a completely different puppy than the hi-ratio cake flour I get at the last remaining flour mill in my area. My neighbor is the general manager there and we have lots of fun talking flour at dinner parties.
The bleaching of the flour is what will allow for more liquid. This process increases the ability of the starch granules to absorb liquid. Most of the time it is a beach flour that will work with a hi-ratio cake recipe rather than an unbleached flour.
You cannot get bleached flour overseas. It is not allowed by law. So you may get a different flour with different results. I do remember someone on the internet having success with flour from overseas when she microwaved it first. But unfortunately I do not have a link. Maybe if you go to The Cake Bible site and look around there you may find a link somewhere.
[/quote]
While I have not tried it, the answer to your question above is yes. Most professionals do not use the creaming method in the kitchen for cakes. It is too time consuming. Instead they use what used to be called the hi-ratio method, or it may still be called that. Anyway, it is like the reverse creaming method. It has been awhile since I read about it, but I believe it is in the book Professional Baking by Wayne Goselin. I may be off on the spelling of the last name.[/quote]
Funny, I just ordered that book from Amazon. Supposed to be getting it tomorrow, can't wait!
http://www.amazon.com/dp/0471783498/?tag=cakecentral-20
Quote by @%username% on %date%
%body%