anyone have suggestions as to what to charge for :

elmo cake pops?

Mrs. Potts(teapot from beauty& the beast)?

Mr Potato head?

i don't want to over/under charge, but it's taken some $$ already just for supplies.

$2.50 to $3.50 each. Of course pricing can depend on the are you live in but that would be a ball park range in my opinion. Good Luck !

Yep i agree with pounds6