REALLY trying to get new clients... and it's just going SO slow. I can't seem to find anyone who's willing to spend money on a cake! Whenever someone calls and I ask what their budget is they're like... $50.. WHAT!?

So, can you all tell me what the price of the average cake is? Do you typically sell cakes in the $50-$100 range? $100-$200 ?

Thanks!

I assume you're talking birthday type cakes and not wedding cakes?

The question is difficult because there are so many factors. The first question should be what is the avg number of servings in our (non-wedding?) cakes? Because most of us price per serving. The avg cost of the cost isnt' good information if the size of the cake is unknown.

BC or fondant? Does the price include gumpaste work or not? What about RI tiaras 'n such? Layered or single sheets? Torted? Filled?

$50 for a cake that serves 100? Great deal!
$50 for a cake that serves 10? Wow, expensive!

It might be better to know avg price per serving and avg servings per cake sold. A flat avg price .... just too many variables.

As part of educating the client, though, an idea would be to reply to their "$50 budget" with something like, "Oh, you're looking for a smaller, simple cake, then. No problem! What I can do for $50 is a 2-layer round 8" that serves 20 with plain BC and a few BC roses."

Well, I shopped around at the local grocery stores and are somewhat similar to their prices b/c people don't think about quality of cake...just prices.

I charge $40 for a full sheet. If I have to buy different decorations for the cake...$45.

Half sheet is $20.



Wedding cakes....$1.00/slice.

weber, when you say "full sheet", are you referring to a 18x24 that serves 108? That's 37 cents a serving.

25 years ago, I sold wedding cake for $1/serving.

I don't sell cakes, but when I was pricing my wedding cake most of the prices were from $2.65-almost $4.00/serving...and that was with minimal decorations.

I put two 11x15 cakes for a full sheet. What would that be: 15x22 right?

I have a per slice price for my celebration cakes and a higher per slice price for my wedding cakes because the wedding cakes are bigger, more elaborate and take longer to do. You don't have to stack a birthday cake!

We sell mostly birthday cakes, our base prices range from $40 (8" round) to $108 (for a 2 layer half sheet). Our sales are roughly bimodal with clusters around $50 and $120.

I live in a very depressed area. I'm lucky someone will pay $40

I dont base my celebration cakes based on per serving..I base it on time. If someone orders a simple round cake, with just icing, and some edging and maybe happy birthday kiddo, it would run 40 dollars for a 8 inch cake.
If they gum paste figurines of Kiddo growing up and flowers climbing up the sides that we have to make, and fancy swirls all around the Happy Birthday Kiddo, then the cake maybe 100 dollars for an 8 inch cake.

Cakiemommy...your two cakes in your portfolio look nice.... it really depends on where you life but maybe you just haven't found your target customer base yet. There will be a rich group of folks that want cakes, and once you nab one or two of them (and if your cakes taste amazing too) they will tell their friends and you will be on your way. Word of mouth will be your best friend. And a nice website will be your second best friend (and gives the word of mouth somewhere to view your work).

$1/serving is way too low for any area though....it would be better for you to donate your cakes to sick children or firehouses or something, than to allow your customers to rip you off that badly. Have you calculated your profit?

I live in a big city area so I'm very fortunate to be able to charge higher prices for my work. Also I have millions of people around this area so out of that its pretty easy to get 2-3 orders per week (don't want more than that). But even here...it did take me several years to get my name out and build up a customer base and also a local reputation. I've lived here 8 years and licensed for 2 years and its been a process to get my name out and find out what works and what doesn't work (as far as advertising or whatever).

I say all that to say...once you find your "niche" it will go better...

My average (as in most ordered size - not the median servings of all orders) serving cake was 130 servings. As the economy has dipped down, it seems my average serving is 70... Hoping that travels upwards again soon. I rarely make a cake that I'll charge less than $500 for because I don't own a bakery, I own a home bakery, it doesn't seem to be worth my time to make a smaller cake. I will sometimes, but a $50 cake that I drive to the store to purchase ingredients, come home, turn on my oven, use the mixer, bake, wash the mixer... ... ... just doesn't balance, even for a 6" round or anything it's not worth it for me. If I was higher volume, that would certainly change.

Wow $40 for a full sheet? You can't get that cheap even at the grocery stores. I have set prices for single layer sheet cakes, buttercream only. My full sheet (2 12x18 put together) is $75. I start at $2.00 per serving for butter cream only for all other cakes and go on up from there depending on the decorations. That is about the average in my part of Ohio. The thing is that people do not want to pay more for cakes, but you've got to sell it. I have lost customers due to price, but not a lot. I tend to book almost all of my inquiries.

I charge $85 for a half sheet single layer and they pay for it in my area

there is a lady in my town selling 2 tier cakes 8" and 6" for $55... i just moved here and one of the things i loved is that here you can bake from your kitchen but she is everywhere... how am i suppose to compete with that?!!! i had a few people calling about my cakes and of course it was her to made those super cheap cakes since mine were more expensive to people... its just crazy...

My average price runs about $250 (these are birthday cakes, not wedding cakes) You may lose some customers but you need to charge what you are worth, not what people want to pay

I just ran numbers today, and I averaged $500 for each cake sold in September. Generally a two tier serving about 25. I'm on the upper scale of things, and I would like to stay anonymous, so sorry for the mystery. But I will tell you this, there is some serious talent on this site by non pros, and some of you need to raise your prices! If we all raise them, there is no room for complaining. We know what we're worth guys. I think this is a great site for beginners and pros alike, lots of help, but I have noticed while lurking as a guest when looking up random photos, that some of you guys are horridly priced.

I charge anywhere from $2.50pp for a simple party cake, and my wedding cakes starting at $3.50pp for a simple wedding cake. People want "Ace of Cakes" and "Cake Boss" cakes, at Wal-mart, Costco, and Sam's Club prices.

I also do cupcakes, and after traveling around this past summer, and paying attention to prices; cups are $3-5 for medium cups. Granted, they are priced that way for store front purposes. Having said that, I only use fresh ingredients, (fresh orange, lime, lemon juices, mint, high end chocolate...) and a lot of my cakes are vegan. So, that's a "commodity" cake.

Hope this helps, and I didn't ramble on. >.<

Oooh... someone famous! >.<

Oh yes. There are several in my area. A lot of secret celebrity weddings and baby showers and 1st birthdays, yada yada. But we don't price per serving, we price per project. We do a lot of pulled sugar and custom mold work, lots of fancy stuff. Very laborious.

I wish I could, but I'm just "one" of the designers/partners/slaves, so I was told it would be like me taking credit for the whole project. And I was actually told to not get personal on this site in particular. So, I will get personal without naming names, did that make sense?