So I ran out of peach get paste, went to get some more and Michaels is out. The Hobby Lobby here is moving and won't open again for a few weeks. I don't have time to order more, so......can I mix other gel pastes together and get something close to flesh?

Try ivory. That's what I always use, sometimes with a little bit of peach added, sometimes not. And for the little bit of peach, if you still have the jar, add a bit of glycerine to it and you'll be able to get the last little bit out.

Actually, I think that Wilton's Copper is the best for flesh.

I agree with Mensch. The copper is the best. I personally use the copper with a bit of peach... but since you hjave none go with tjust the copper

When I tried the copper before, it was too pink. Was I using too much?

I find paprika works well, just a tiny bit.

Probably. I start with tiny amounts and add more as needed. It's easy to take too much at first.

Use the search box and type in Carta de Colores. It is a wonderful chart submitted by awiscar. Skin tone is on left hand side near the bottom. Hope this helps

I use ivory as well and enhance cheeks, etc. with petal dust. In reality, more Caucasians have golden undertones to their skin vs. the peach and oranges that one derives with copper, peach and paprika.

I also use a teeny tiny bit of copper for flesh colored things.