How Do I Substitute Butter For Oil?

Baking By -Tubbs Updated 9 Oct 2009 , 4:08am by -Tubbs

 -Tubbs  Cake Central Cake Decorator Profile
-Tubbs Posted 8 Oct 2009 , 3:45pm
post #1 of 9

I have a request for chocolate cake, from a customer who specifically requested butter as an ingredient. I usually use the Dark Chocolate cake recipe from this site, which uses half a cup of oil and no butter. If I wanted to make the same cake, would I just use half a cup of melted butter instead?

And vice versa, most of my other recipes are butter-based. Could I sub oil for some of the butter?

Thanks for any help!

8 replies
 -K8memphis  Cake Central Cake Decorator Profile
-K8memphis Posted 8 Oct 2009 , 3:53pm
post #2 of 9

Sometimes that works out for other people--it doesn't usually work out for me.

But butter has water in it--kind of a lot nowadays too so if It was me, I'd hold back on some of the liqiud in the recipe and up the butter itself a few tablespoons-ish.

Someone smart will chime in who does it--

Me? I would find a specific recipe that already has butter but...

 ebredhawk  Cake Central Cake Decorator Profile
ebredhawk Posted 8 Oct 2009 , 6:05pm
post #3 of 9

DH makes a chocolate butter cake mix that you could doctor up to your liking. just a recommendation though.. those cakes are VERY moist so if you're doing any kind of stacking with them, make sure you have lots of support in place.

 -K8memphis  Cake Central Cake Decorator Profile
-K8memphis Posted 8 Oct 2009 , 6:54pm
post #4 of 9

Toba's got a chocolate cake with butter~~

Have I b*tched lately about how my husband moved my cake books and I can't find anything anymore? grr

But I imagine all the biggies have butter based choco cakes--Scott Clark Woolley's choco cake is pretty famous--not sure about the butter factor.

Colette's chocolate cake in the Christmas book is made with shortening.

Y'know what though--I'd a never taken the order.

 -K8memphis  Cake Central Cake Decorator Profile
-K8memphis Posted 8 Oct 2009 , 6:57pm
post #5 of 9

Yes Scott's uses butter

Baking 9-1-1 has a chocolate cake using butter.

 -Tubbs  Cake Central Cake Decorator Profile
-Tubbs Posted 8 Oct 2009 , 10:47pm
post #6 of 9

Thanks! I'll think I'll just experiment with subbing half of the oil with butter and maybe reducing the liquids just a bit. It's only an 8" round, so it's not 'specially high risk. I'm sure it will be fine - I just need to be able to look the customer in the eye and tell her there's butter in it!!

 Jayde  Cake Central Cake Decorator Profile
Jayde Posted 8 Oct 2009 , 10:50pm
post #7 of 9

You know what I do? If a customer asks for a 'butter' cake, I add in a tbsp of butter flavor and possibly sub some of the water for melted butter. I dont omit the oil though. The oil is what makes it moist, if you sub with butter most of the water evaporates and your cake ends up dry.

 indydebi  Cake Central Cake Decorator Profile
indydebi Posted 8 Oct 2009 , 10:57pm
post #8 of 9
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jayde

You know what I do? If a customer asks for a 'butter' cake, I add in a tbsp of butter flavor and possibly sub some of the water for melted butter. I dont omit the oil though. The oil is what makes it moist, if you sub with butter most of the water evaporates and your cake ends up dry.



I was reading this thread hoping someone more knowledgeable than me would address this. Anytime I've used butter in a cake, it's been brittle and dry. I read on another thread that oil is 'fat" but butter is "milk and water" (simplistically speaking). Jayde, your explanation helps me understand the "why" of my failed cakes!

 -Tubbs  Cake Central Cake Decorator Profile
-Tubbs Posted 9 Oct 2009 , 4:08am
post #9 of 9

Thanks for the extra info. I'll leave all the oil in and trade some of the milk for melted butter. I'll let you know how it turns out - this cake is super-moist, so it wouldn't hurt if it goes a little less so.

Quote by @%username% on %date%

%body%