which one is a good one to purchase?

I think it's been mixed opinions on here. Some really like the s u gar cr aft gun but others think the Makin's Ultimate Clay Extruder is better. All I can tell you is that Makin's is cheaper!

Here's a pic with tips on how to clean the Makin's extruder:
http://www.makinsclay.com/US/eng/products/ultimate.htm

Yesterday, I went to my favorite cake supply store in San Antonio.
I was asked, what I thought of the extruder they are carrying today

I own the black and red guy, That is the deal they are carrying.

I told her the truth, it's too little. It's not the fact I can't get a full thing for an 8 inch cake. It's a big huge PITA. I can't get stuff for a big cake.

If I haven't trashed it enough. It hurts, when you're trying to do stuff.