Gritty Buttercream Icing

Decorating By snoopy3 Updated 16 Aug 2009 , 5:59pm by all4cake

 snoopy3  Cake Central Cake Decorator Profile
snoopy3 Posted 4 Feb 2009 , 4:34am
post #1 of 13

I got a complaint that my icing was a little gritty. The recipe I use is 1/2 cup butter, 1/2 cup shortening, 4 cups icing sugar, pinch salt, 1 tsp vanilla and 2-3 tbsp milk. I am in Canada and I use Roger's Icing sugar.

Any suggestions??

12 replies
 MacsMom  Cake Central Cake Decorator Profile
MacsMom Posted 4 Feb 2009 , 4:46am
post #2 of 13

Is icing sugar the same as powdered sugar? I use popcorn salt to reduce grit from salt crystals, and I beat my buttercream for a very long time to give it a nicely whipped texture. I also add meringue powder to help it along (2 T per 2 lbs of powdered sugar).

 snoopy3  Cake Central Cake Decorator Profile
snoopy3 Posted 4 Feb 2009 , 4:48am
post #3 of 13

sorry, yes it is powder sugar. I can't find popcorn salt anywhere here, I just use regular table salt. Doesn't mixing it for a long time make a lot air bubbles??

 gerripje  Cake Central Cake Decorator Profile
gerripje Posted 4 Feb 2009 , 4:50am
post #4 of 13

Hi, I'm in Canada and use Roger's also! Do you live near a Walmart? They have icing sugar that is 100% cane sugar as opposed to the beet sugar. I've asked if there is a difference and everyone didn't think so. I can't say that I've made a whole lot of batches of icing and use a similar recipe to you, but sometimes I notice a difference in the sugars. Maybe it has to with the weather?? I don't know for sure, I have read that sometimes you just get a bag of sugar that's 'off' somehow. Where abouts are you? Here in southern Alberta the humidity can change so much from day to day, but usually it's dry. I guess I really didn't have any good answer for ya!!

 snoopy3  Cake Central Cake Decorator Profile
snoopy3 Posted 4 Feb 2009 , 4:52am
post #5 of 13

Thanks! I am in Edmonton, so yes, I can definetly find a Walmart icon_wink.gif
It is not really gritty, just a little and it is almost always like that... and I have made a lot of batches of icing. I don't know!

 newnancy  Cake Central Cake Decorator Profile
newnancy Posted 4 Feb 2009 , 4:55am
post #6 of 13

A few weeks back there was another thread on CC about this topic & discussing cane sugar vs. beet sugar, maybe you can find it. I believe Dominos is cane sugar & that is better. HTH

 gerripje  Cake Central Cake Decorator Profile
gerripje Posted 4 Feb 2009 , 4:58am
post #7 of 13

I know what you're talking about, actually. Sometimes when I'm kneading the icing sugar into fondant or gum paste it has such a weird feeling to it that gives me the creeps!! I know that sounds strange!! It seems like it's always hit and miss with me, some icing is good and some isn't.

 gerripje  Cake Central Cake Decorator Profile
gerripje Posted 4 Feb 2009 , 4:59am
post #8 of 13

I guess it's kinda hard not being close to a Walmart any more. icon_redface.gif

 gerripje  Cake Central Cake Decorator Profile
gerripje Posted 4 Feb 2009 , 5:01am
post #9 of 13

By the way, where do you find cake decorating stuff in Edmonton? Is there a big store or do you have to rely on online ordering and whatever Michael's has?

 bcake1960  Cake Central Cake Decorator Profile
bcake1960 Posted 4 Feb 2009 , 5:08am
post #10 of 13

I have a batch everynow and then that has a gritty texture.. I just assumed it was the weather.. humidity or what ever.. In the summer time we cool our house with an evaporative cooler.. (water cooler) I really have to keep my powdered sugar in a tightly sealed container or I find it does make my frosting gritty.. I really think it is the weather or what ever the powdered sugar has been exposed to on the way to you... your not alone...

 stephanie214  Cake Central Cake Decorator Profile
stephanie214 Posted 4 Feb 2009 , 6:31am
post #11 of 13

Try mixing the salt in with your sugar instead of adding it straight to your cream mixture.

HTH thumbs_up.gif

 MacsMom  Cake Central Cake Decorator Profile
MacsMom Posted 4 Feb 2009 , 3:40pm
post #12 of 13
Quote:
Originally Posted by snoopy3

sorry, yes it is powder sugar. I can't find popcorn salt anywhere here, I just use regular table salt. Doesn't mixing it for a long time make a lot air bubbles??




Funny, I can't find it either! So I grind my salt in a coffee grinder. A brand new grinder would be best so you don't have to fight hidden coffee particles. It's much, much cheaper than buying popcorn salt, too icon_wink.gif

And no, air bubbles don't form. It just gets whipped - lighter and fluffier.
Here is my recipe - I use all the extra stuff to help reduce the sweetness (I know, it's frosting!). This recipe crusts.

1-2/3 c hi-ratio shortening (if using Crisco, use 2 cups)
2 lbs PS
1/4 c flour  
2 tablespoons cornstarch
2 tablespoons meringue powder
1 teaspoon popcorn salt
2 T corn syrup
3/4 cup vanilla coffee creamer
1 oz Wilton butter flavor (any butter flavor)

 all4cake  Cake Central Cake Decorator Profile
all4cake Posted 16 Aug 2009 , 5:59pm
post #13 of 13

A couple of months ago, I ordered flavoring. My regular brand (alcohol based) was out so I ordered a different (reliable) brand. I didn't realize until I went to use it that it was oil based. Still, I thought it'd work. So, I used it. OMG!!!!!!!!!!! It was grainy to the point of being pebbly! I could not figure out wth caused this freakish result.

Fast forward a bit...I finally got to order my flavorings. Made icing again...perfect.

Fast forward a bit more...out of regular so I retrieved the now "back up" flavorings. Crap! It's pebbly again! I just dumped 30 bucks+ of freakin' buttercream! So, if ya'll happen to use oil based flavorings, that may be wreaking havoc on your icing....

this has not had full experimental measures taken to determine the validity of my claim....

Just a thought for everyone to check out....

Quote by @%username% on %date%

%body%