Does anyone know where to buy inexpensive cake toppers like deer, trees, farm animals, fences, anything but picks? I tried Oriental Trading but didn't really find anything there that I liked. Thanks!

You can try www.safariLtd.com, they make toys in the shape of all types of animals, including farm animals if that's what you're looking for. I don't know how cheap they are, but I've seen them at Michael's in the kids' craft sections, and they sell them at museum shops (they're considered educational toys because they're pretty realistic.) My kids had a bunch when they were little, and they're good quality toys, so if it's for a birthday cake the kids could play with them after they're used on the cake.

bump

Do you have any state parks near you? Most of them have gift shops and carry things like that.
OR I've seen some at craft shops like Michael's.