interesting

I'm so glad that they had to pay up. $260 for that cake was a steal to begin with.
Man was Judge Judy's judgment quick though.

very interesting.

Did you catch it was a year later and they hadn't said anything about the cake quality until then??

judge judy tells it like it is...i just love her!

i can't believe that lady is complaining a year later. why didn't she say anything the next day?...and that price was a definite steal!

hahaha! I love it! Its a Prop! hahahahahaha!

Thank you for posting that..it made my day!

I just love Judge Judy -

And wait a year to say it was DRY - give me a break. They just wanted the cake for FREE.

actually, a year old cake IS dry, no? hahahahahaha!

Wow! Some people never cease to amaze me...
Thank you for sharing!

does anybody even eat the "aniversary cake" anyway? judge judy is a riot-got the pics, people don't care after they've eaten all the food so what's a little piece of cake?!...she should be greatful she only had to pay $260 i would have made her pay more (to include the costs of coming to court, wasting time, i mean a year later?!?!)

Holy friggin crap and we thought we had stories to tell. . . A WHOLE YEAR!!!!

I was on the edge of my seat. I wish she had said more than "treat it as a prop" and taken the time to speak about the law regarding such issues so that she could have educated a few people. She was being funny but the cake looked good and didn't have any structural flaws, they ate it, it was a bargain, they waited quite a bit of time to complain ect. The judgement was quick because there was nothing to say. She is sooo funny but I wish she had said more.

Some people truly have gut!!! I would charge her interest for the delay in payment. I charge more for cake 3 size smaller.

anyone notice it was a cake with stairs? (I wonder if it had a fountain too)

I agree with poshcakedesigns- they just wanted a free cake!

I worked in a floral shop for 3 years, and once a bride e-mailed us this nasty complaint letter demanding a refund almost a year later! The owner sent her a courteous, but matter-of-fact letter in response stating "nope, sorry." This was a bridezilla, and we had kept accurate notes on all phone converstations, consults, etc. so most of her "complaints" were about situations that she actually had fabricated. I think she was hoping that after that long we would have forgotton what actually happened and blindly give her a refund!

Thanks fot sharing! I'm so happy that Judge Judy decided in her favor. Are you kidding me, a year later, whatever!! What, did they just realize that the cake was dry? Something should have been said the day of or right after. People are something else. I love Judge Judy she is so to the point, lol.

As far as the stairs, I was thinking the same thing Loriemom!! Too funny!


Anywho, I love Judge Judy and want to have her attitude when I grow up!
When I am not sure about a decision, I aske myself, What Would Judge Judy Do?

This is amazing to me that someone would even think of asking for a refund or not paying for something a year later!

Just another example of why I get payment in full before the cake is delivered.

She's had a few wedding cake cases in her years and she's always come out on the side of the decorators. I love Judge Judy too.

Judge Judy is amazing... She's no Mother Teresa. I love the way she handles her cases and how she makes sure everything she says was understood... more power to her.. she's no wimp.

Yay!
Judge Judy made the right call.

Gotta love her!LOL

I found this thread waaayyy late, and now the video has been removed so I didn't get to see it, but I was curious as to how often this happens, so I went to youtube and found one from The People's Court..

I don't understand why you would sue someone for a misspelled name, especially if you spell your child's name so strangely, like this woman did, but she DID stress how important it was to her. She has obviously never seen cake wrecks! I do wonder why the cake cracked, though..