Wow!! Just logged on today to see that the mystery has NOT been solved!!!
This is gonna bug me all day now That Bob the Builder guess was so close.

OMG sweetresults....i have had that cutter in my box for forever and could never figure out what it was....thank u thank u thank u

anyone else have a cutter they don't know what it is? If so please post lets keep this game going. This is so fun to read. As for the acorn the side view reminds me of elmer fud from Bugs Bunny..lol...

At least ONE mystery is solved

A little update on my cookie cutter mystery. I stopped by the store and asked around about the cutter,well the owners new the cutter but did not know what it was.They said it had been so long that they forgot what it was. The one lady said she always thought it was a Girl with pig tails. But another one said she didn't think so. It was ordered from a catalog but they did not know which one it came from.They told me that they would research and try to find out for me. If and when I find out I will let you all know.

So the quest for the name of cutter goes on!!

okay... i turned my head upside down..to see what it lookd like and if you turn it so the "handle"looking things are at the bottom...looks like a hat..perhaps a cowboy hat???

not sure..i'm thinking mabey they jusy just kinda had the hat sorta "pinched" at the bottom.... i drew it out on paper....can't think of anything besides a hat....

I bought cutters from Off the Beaten Path the other day and I emailed them the picture - they had not seen it before, but thought it was a lamb's face.

I don't know how to get the picture on here but, I was just shopping at kitchengifts and under the "furniture" cookie cutters the 1st one is a chair that resembles this!?! Maybe?????

It looks like a green pepper with growths on the sides. It also kind of looks like a frog if you turn it over. I dunno, maybe I was looking at it too long. Let us know if you figure out what it is. This will be driving me crazy until I find out. Ahhhhhh the suspense!!!!

still dont know what it is.. , I am so puzzled!

my hubby said it looked like a muffin (he is obsessed with them though, so you can ignore that)

i went to a school where the mascot was a bulldog, and the cutter reminds me of that. maybe its just years of seeing the bulldog face, but that is what i thought of.

Okay...my two cents worth...it looks like a slice of bread to me!! count me in for the cookie cutter chain!! I'd love to do that! I just did that with socks and got 36 pairs for sending one pair. We did funky looking socks for this!!

My first thought was a slice of bread too. I'm curious to find out as well!!

well now i am sad...I have managed to break the cutter.
How about all of us printing the picture and using it as a stencil to see what we come up with? Anyone in?

i'm game!!

so maybe it was warped or squished to begin with and the stress of that is why it broke?

I have some dough left over, gonna see what I come up with!

well it broke where the seem was. It was made of thin metal/tin material.
i am going to do mine tomorrow and will post.

i just saved the pic. i have a ton of graduation cookies due this weekend. i hope i can fit it in

I don't know, you'd think if it was an apple with a worm in it, it would only be coming out of one end of the apple, kwim? No clue what it is!

i am trying to load my mystery cookie and having trouble...i am going to try to resize the pic and post later.

here is my mystery cookie, I am looking forward to seeing what everyone else comes up with.

Pearl70,
Your cookie is so cute.
How did you do the face?

thank you...it is mmf the hair is painted on with food coloring and the face is edible markers.

all i know is that it looks like pipi longstocking! laurie in michigan

Thanks Pearl70
I want to make some cookies, I don't think I'll have time this weekend.