kstgelais4 Posted 7 May 2006 , 6:56pm
post #1 of

What a disaster! They tasted terrible, and they looked worse. The dough was tooo soft, and didn't hold. I froze rolled out dough overnight, and it was still soft. I figured out a little of the problem, but it shouldn't have made them tast so bad. I used margerine instead of butter and I think that's what made them so soft. But what else could have gone wrong!?! I made them in my KA exactly how the directions said! I just don't get it. On the other hand, I used the Alice's cookie icing, and it was fantastic!
Any help would be appreciated!
Kelly

7 replies
manyacakes Posted 7 May 2006 , 8:17pm
post #2 of

i made a batch yesterday. i agree that it might be your butter. were other ingredients in your cabinet for a while? i know sometimes flour can get rancid maybe that affected the taste.

good luck with your next batch.

manya

ladyonzlake Posted 7 May 2006 , 8:20pm
post #3 of

As I said on an earlier post I prefer Martha Stewarts recipe over the No Fail. Give it a try. I think the flavor is so much better and I divide my dough into 3rds. I roll each 3rd out between parchment paper and refrigerate for 30 minutes, then I cut out my cookies. Be sure to keep your dough cold for less spreading. Oh, and I use 1 1/2 tsp Pure Vanilla extract and 1/2 tsp Almond. Here's a link
http://www.marthastewart.com/page.jhtml?type=content&id=recipe1266

golfgirl1227 Posted 8 May 2006 , 3:46am
post #4 of

I'm betting the margarine was the problem. Well, at least with the staying soft thing. Not sure about the taste. I think they taste great, I add almond extract as well as vanilla too though.

antonia74 Posted 8 May 2006 , 3:54am
post #5 of

margarine can't normally just be substituted for butter. It is soft, has a much higher moisture content and isn't the same product pound for pound. thumbsdown.gif Won't work!

Ladivacrj Posted 8 May 2006 , 1:51pm
post #6 of

I have to disagree with Antonia, I have used margarine everytime and it has worked perfectly.

You have to make sure that you are using margarine instead of veggie oil spread product, there is a difference.

They taste fantastic, but I also use almond and butter flavorings.

I would try again, but make sure you use a real margarine.

kstgelais4 Posted 8 May 2006 , 2:22pm
post #7 of
Quote:
Originally Posted by manyacakes

i made a batch yesterday. i agree that it might be your butter. were other ingredients in your cabinet for a while? i know sometimes flour can get rancid maybe that affected the taste.

good luck with your next batch.

manya




Nope, brand new bag of flour. I know for sure the margerine was the problem of the softness now, but I still can't figure out why they tasted so bad. Maybe I just don't prefer that taste. Should they taste like regular sugar cookies? My Husband is normally the baker in my house. I am just the decorator. lol. He makes killer sugar cookies, but they are good for cutouts, that's why I thought I would try that recipe. I think maybe I'll try it once more with butter, and if it doesn't work, I will move on. Thanks ladies!
Kelly

Samsgranny Posted 8 May 2006 , 5:03pm
post #8 of

thanks for the post, I will give the MS recipe a try.

Quote by @%username% on %date%

%body%